Are there any single-driver bookshelf speakers from budget to very high-end that have a frequency response range from ~100Hz to 20KHz and above for home Hi-Fi use? That could be paired with a sub-woofer and accordingly adjust the frequency cut-off at the sub-woofer end that match the bookshelf speaker's starting frequency. Like the ones without any crossovers or coaxial speakers, just one single speaker driver with a sensitivity of at least 85db SPL. Most of them can be built as a DIY project, but those single-driver speakers are mostly for professional sound environment settings like recording or live venues.
Single Driver Bookshelf Speakers?
- Thread starter Kenneth Fernandes
- Start date
Dom
Well-known member
Gray
Well-known member
If those ones are bookshelf sized, what's to stop you using them at home?
Al ears
Well-known member
Single driver full-range speakers, by their very design, tend to be large floorstanders.
Co-axial possibly as they have two drivers like MOFI Sourcepoint 10 or 8.
www.mofielectronics.com
Co-axial possibly as they have two drivers like MOFI Sourcepoint 10 or 8.
MoFi Electronics SourcePoint 10 Loudspeakers [Pair]
MoFi Electronics SourcePoint 10 Loudspeakers an original Andrew Jones design speaker. Designed from the ground up, to deliver the highest sound quality and value!
www.mofielectronics.com
Currently, all those speakers still have some sort of crossover including the KEF's.
Also, there aren't any stereo amplifiers (integrated/all-in-one) that have a frequency control I have come across, where you can set the output speaker frequency from ~100Hz, and the same frequency can be set on the sub-woofer low pass frequency control. This would bring a great number of products from various manufacturers in the single-driver bookshelf speakers and audio electronics (amplifiers) market.
Also, there aren't any stereo amplifiers (integrated/all-in-one) that have a frequency control I have come across, where you can set the output speaker frequency from ~100Hz, and the same frequency can be set on the sub-woofer low pass frequency control. This would bring a great number of products from various manufacturers in the single-driver bookshelf speakers and audio electronics (amplifiers) market.
GSV Ethics Gradient
Moderator
I hate to say it, but I genuinely doubt that.
Al ears
Well-known member
As I said single driver (full range) drivers are not going to work in a bookshelf sized speaker.
It's far more economical and profitable for a company to manufacture, as there is more scope for R&D and testing than having completed a DIY project at home.
There is nothing stopping from having a single-driver speaker without any internal circuitry, just a speaker driver connected to output terminals. All of the frequency management could be done at the amplifier end that controls the output frequency to the speaker and a sub-woofer out. Although, I haven't heard any amp could do that.
DougK1
Well-known member
Think this is all a bark up a non-existent tree, or just plain barking. I'm only here for the music.
twinkletoes
Well-known member
DougK1
Well-known member
Just custom built a nice cherry veneer pair online, nearly €6000. Should I audition first?
Gray
Well-known member
His bookshelves might be Tannoy Westminster size 🙂
But yes, those Rehdeko ones are also big.
...and both of those use dual concentric drivers don't they? - so would still contain the crossover that he doesn't want 😐
Al ears
Well-known member
Only ones I have seen had Lowther full range transducers and they don't come in small boxes....
And I still don't quite understand what he's trying to achieve or why.
Vincent Kars
Well-known member
The problem with full range drivers is that they are not full range. I do think calling them wide banders is more apt as they don't go low (can indeed be compensated by a sub) nor high as the treble is often rolled of at 18 kHz. This can be compensated by getting older.
The closest we can get is a 2.1 where the bass is handled by a woofer, the mid range by the woofers of the satellites and the treble by the tweeters.
Of course there are full range systems claiming 40 - 20.000 Hz (without specifying the tolerance) like https://voxativ.berlin/ampeggio-2023. With 40x120x40cm not exactly bookshelf but at only $13,900.00 it is yours.
The closest we can get is a 2.1 where the bass is handled by a woofer, the mid range by the woofers of the satellites and the treble by the tweeters.
Of course there are full range systems claiming 40 - 20.000 Hz (without specifying the tolerance) like https://voxativ.berlin/ampeggio-2023. With 40x120x40cm not exactly bookshelf but at only $13,900.00 it is yours.
Last edited:
twinkletoes
Well-known member
might be a good idea!Just custom built a nice cherry veneer pair online, nearly €6000. Should I audition first?
daytona600
Well-known member
Voxativ HAGEN 5000euros
Frequency Response
60 - 20.000 Hz
Elipson Planet passive , Active version 50 Hz - 20 KHz
Frequency Response
60 - 20.000 Hz
Elipson Planet passive , Active version 50 Hz - 20 KHz
Last edited:
Single-driver speakers, I mean a single material drive unit too. Similar to the drive units of an over-ear headphone like the Sennheiser HD 560S and others in the line-up, but with a bigger size and specification that cater to a living room. (~120Hz and above)
For the low frequencies, they could be paired with a sub-woofer.
The ones mentioned above have two different materials in the construction of the speaker unit, a metal insert in the centre of the driver and a different cone material.
For the low frequencies, they could be paired with a sub-woofer.
The ones mentioned above have two different materials in the construction of the speaker unit, a metal insert in the centre of the driver and a different cone material.
GSV Ethics Gradient
Moderator
nopiano
Well-known member
Yes, and they are the only design I’ve seen and heard more than twice, so they are doing something right. But they are still more costly than excellent three-way floorstanders, so remain a niche choice.
Generally, it’s a nice idea, but very hard to implement. Hence, never really made commercial sense.
Sibelius single driver, natural oak, floor standing loudspeakers
Have you been searching for high quality loudspeakers? Pearl Acoustics, Sibelius loudspeakers are the best choice for people who want life-like performance, especially for acoustic music. Loved by musicians, recording engineers and music lovers the world over! Get the best in natural sounding...
pearlacoustics.com
twinkletoes
Well-known member
they look to be very nice speakers TBH and nicely made.Yes, and they are the only design I’ve seen and heard more than twice, so they are doing something right. But they are still more costly than excellent three-way floorstanders, so remain a niche choice.
Generally, it’s a nice idea, but very hard to implement. Hence, never really made commercial sense.
Sibelius single driver, natural oak, floor standing loudspeakers
Have you been searching for high quality loudspeakers? Pearl Acoustics, Sibelius loudspeakers are the best choice for people who want life-like performance, especially for acoustic music. Loved by musicians, recording engineers and music lovers the world over! Get the best in natural sounding...
DougK1
Well-known member
nopiano
Well-known member
Indeed, they look great to my eyes, and the owner/designer is very interesting to listen to. As is the way these days, he even has his own YouTube channel!
I have created another post that explains in more detail.
Question - Stereo Amplifier with Frequency Control?
I am looking for a Stereo Wireless Streaming Amplifier(all-in-one) that has the option to route all the low frequencies (say less than ~120Hz) to the sub-woofer out and the remaining frequencies(~120Hz - 20kHz and above) amplified to the speaker out. I haven't come across any amps yet that could...
forums.whathifi.com
GSV Ethics Gradient
Moderator
Similar threads
TRENDING THREADS
-
-
-
Question Can I connect these Tannoy speakers to my Sony TV?
- Started by Timjameslucas
- Replies: 1
-
-
-
-
Facebook
Twitter
Instagram