Rega Elicit mk5 4ohm: overheating is real 😟

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the What HiFi community: the world's leading independent guide to buying and owning hi-fi and home entertainment products.

manicm

Well-known member
Have you tried (for example) the Fosi V3 David?
20 times less expensive than your £2k figure.
Too cheap to be any good?
A lower class of D?
I might have said so.....before I tried one - and I'm not alone.
(True, the measurers claim some speaker dependency at HF - but they also reckon that's been corrected by the feedback implementation in the new Monoblocks 🤔)

The Fosi V3 is not a 300w amplifier, why are you obsessed with it? All very well ASR giving it a glowing review, without stating what speakers he's tested it with. Many other reviews as well. I seriously doubt it will drive those Elacs adequately.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Revolutions

Gray

Well-known member
The Fosi V3 is not a 300w amplifier, why are you obsessed with it? All very well ASR giving it a glowing review, without stating what speakers he's tested it with. Many other reviews as well. I seriously doubt it will drive those Elacs adequately.
Where did I say it was a 300 watt amp?
I know it is not.
And I've read about it's reported issue with speaker-dependent HF.
I'm not 'obsessed' by it - but it's fair to say that I like the value it provides.

I made no reference to ASR either...though I think I did see some 'reviewer' blasting it momentarily into a 1 ohm test load.

And that's the main point in the context of this thread - it probably (almost certainly) wouldn't be switching itself off if faced with the OPs speakers (and from what some of us have heard of it, I doubt it would even sound strained).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Revolutions
I'm not too interested whether an amplifier can momentarily cover a 4ohm/3ohm/2ohm load etc, but whether it can do so over a normal listening session, and sometimes in weather like this. You have to have faith in your equipment to be able to "use it and forget it", you don't want to be worrying whether it is going to overheat, or start producing negative characteristics because it can't handle what you want it to do.

For the last few weeks (except for when I was at the show), I've been listening to Magnepan Magneplanar LRS speakers, which state 4ohms, but the Stereophile review states they act more like 3.3ohms, and dip to 2.8ohms. Initially I was using a Bel Canto E1X integrated, even though I haven't used this amp with anything like this before, but it seems to handle Perlisten speakers pretty well, that drop to similar impedances. After I got the Hegel H390 back off loan, I swapped for that, knowing they double in output when the impedance halves, and knowing it can handle 2ohms easily. I honestly wouldn't trust something not much bigger than a pan Apple TV box to remain stable when the going gets tough. If anything goes wrong, I don't want to lose any expensive drivers! From what I'm told, Class D amps can let go dramatically, and take everything with them.

I'm always on the look out for amps that can handle low impedances, but I'd need to read solid data on its abilities in that respect to be able to trust it. The £2k figure I mentioned was a rough one, and for the most part, I'd say it's likely higher. Class AB amplifiers need big components to deal with it, so won't be cheap, and I'm not generally convinced that Class D can handle it properly, as even the Anthem M1 monoblocks which are 1kW into 8ohms and double into 4k don't give any ratings below 3ohms, and that rating isn't in line to show a doubling down towards 2ohms.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Revolutions

manicm

Well-known member
Where did I say it was a 300 watt amp?
I know it is not.
And I've read about it's reported issue with speaker-dependent HF.
I'm not 'obsessed' by it - but it's fair to say that I like the value it provides.

I made no reference to ASR either...though I think I did see some 'reviewer' blasting it momentarily into a 1 ohm test load.

And that's the main point in the context of this thread - it probably (almost certainly) wouldn't be switching itself off if faced with the OPs speakers (and from what some of us have heard of it, I doubt it would even sound strained).

It won't drive those Elacs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Revolutions

Ian AV

Well-known member
Apr 13, 2023
33
14
545
Visit site
If your amplifier can't cope with nominal 4 Ohm speakers, then it's replace the amp or speakers which ever is your choice.
Otherwise, if you are happy with the combination and the amp can handle 4 Ohm loads then add forced cooling.
I had a Quad amp that ran darned hot into 4 Ohms and output was reduced to cope by the amp itself. So I added external cooling and that cured the too hot to handle cooling fins at the back.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Revolutions

Jasonovich

Well-known member
I couldn't sleep, it's almost 1:30 am. Crazy hot but this lovely baby keeps the room chilled.

1719534262502.png
This Klarstein Ethos High Performance Metal Pedestal Fan cost me £130 but worth every penny. Probably keep those 2Ohm amps from overheating, yeah there's the noise, Whoosh Whoosh..

 
  • Like
Reactions: Revolutions

gasolin

Well-known member
Read my posts, read the official specs of this specific Elac speaker.

Type: 2 1⁄2-Way, bass reflex
Woofer: 2 x 180 mm Ø, AS XR cone
Midrange: (180 mm)
Tweeter: JET 5
Frequency: 450 | 2550 Hz
Frequency range (IEC 268-5): 28 – 50000 Hz
Sensitivity: 88,5 dB at 2,83 V/m
Suitable for amplifiers: 4 – 8 Ω
Rec. amplifier power: 40 – 400 W/channel
Nominal/peak power handling: 150 W | 220 W
Nominal impedance: 4 Ω | 3,6 Ω at 180 Hz
Height x width x depth: 1142 x 276 x 332 mm
Weight: 27,1 kg

My speakers go down to 3.8 ohm my amp handles it without any problems

2024-06-28 10_38_39-Enceinte Bibliothèque Hi-Fi - Esprit EZ Titus (Paire) – Google Chrome.jpg

Get a min 2x 100 watt amp in 8 ohm or try a big power amp 200 watt in 8 ohm or more so you don't get close to using all of the power the amp has to play loud

Pa power amp is always an option but can be noisy do to a fan(s)

go for one with big heatsinks and ventilation holes
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Revolutions

manicm

Well-known member
Type: 2 1⁄2-Way, bass reflex
Woofer: 2 x 180 mm Ø, AS XR cone
Midrange: (180 mm)
Tweeter: JET 5
Frequency: 450 | 2550 Hz
Frequency range (IEC 268-5): 28 – 50000 Hz
Sensitivity: 88,5 dB at 2,83 V/m
Suitable for amplifiers: 4 – 8 Ω
Rec. amplifier power: 40 – 400 W/channel
Nominal/peak power handling: 150 W | 220 W
Nominal impedance: 4 Ω | 3,6 Ω at 180 Hz
Height x width x depth: 1142 x 276 x 332 mm
Weight: 27,1 kg

Nominal impedance: 4 Ω | 3,6 Ω at 180 Hz

Forget the rest of the specs Gasolin, this is the only one that matters. This is a 4ohm speaker dipping to 3.6ohms.

This speaker in its latest iteration also costs around 4200 GBP.

Maybe the Fosi can drive it sufficiently, but it's a risk one would have to take.

Back to the OP, regardless of the Rega's weaknesses and taking into account his smaller room, it would be more cost efficient to replace his speaker rather than his amp, assuming there's nothing wrong with the Rega. But that should be entirely his decision, and all that matters is a system which will be reliable and make him happy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Revolutions

gasolin

Well-known member
Back to the OP, regardless of the Rega's weaknesses and taking into account his smaller room, it would be more cost efficient to replace his speaker rather than his amp, assuming there's nothing wrong with the Rega. But that should be entirely his decision, and all that matters is a system which will be reliable and make him happy.

Elac NAVIS ARB51 Powered speakers (the amps match the speaker)

Use his rega as a preamp or if wast or money (not using the built in amp in the rega) get something from nad,rotel or what you can find of a good quality

2024-06-28 11_06_35-Elac NAVIS ARB51 _ Audiocompagniet.dk – Google Chrome.jpg

Rega AYA same price as the elacs Impedance: 6 Ω Sensitivity: 89.5dB
2024-06-28 11_15_36-Rega AYA gulvhøjttalere _ Audiocompagniet.dk – Google Chrome.jpg
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Revolutions

gasolin

Well-known member
I would find a big power amp and listen,see how that performs

Does it also get to hot,shuts down

Im not shure what you most want to change, speakers or amp

Have you tried to place it so it has enought space air to get rid of the hot air ?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Revolutions

spl84

Well-known member
Jul 17, 2023
120
70
670
Visit site
My Focal speakers dip to, I think, 2.8 ohms. I currently use a cheap Sony I bought at bestbuy for like 150 bucks. It has a min impedance of 6ohm and it actually does pretty well. I know my speaker would sound much better with a higher end amp, but I've never noticed any overheating, shutdowns or anything of the sort.
 

Stuart83

Well-known member
Jul 22, 2023
481
404
1,270
Visit site
Naim are known for driving heavier loads of 2-4 ohms and fully graphed consistently online at taking them.

Yet I've driven 4/6ohm loads with all manner of mid range amps without problem over the years that weren't super expensive.
I know my old over mentioned Pioneer a-400 drives them consistently and at 30plus years I'd say that's reliably.

The Arcam I have does 6 to a 4 ohm dip and did for over a yr until changing speakers.
I'm not sure that manufacturers would post such a claim otherwise in today's world without a disclaimer such as found with Rega.

This business of thinking only high end gear drives a lower ohm load hasn't been my findings.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Revolutions

Revolutions

Well-known member
Well I’ve landed on a short-term experiment.

A sideways swap with the amp feels like a waste of time. I don’t want to be rushed into upgrading as next step up will probably by my final one. It would be nice to shop around for that at leisure, when I have the money. Not a knee-jerk “gotta replace the amp” credit card purchase.

With that in mind, I went in search of a solution I could live with for a while & wouldn’t break the bank. I’ve spent a total of £360 (+ £70 for a transformer).

All will be revealed soon 😊
 

TRENDING THREADS

Latest posts