New amplifier: my long journey...

Page 14 - Seeking answers? Join the What HiFi community: the world's leading independent guide to buying and owning hi-fi and home entertainment products.

CnoEvil

New member
Aug 21, 2009
556
14
0
Visit site
Neuphonix said:
For me the Yamaha AV has an EQ system called IPAQ which should allow me to balance the fronts with the rest of the set-up, with the AMS set at 12o'clock or 40 or whatever. Then my harmony remote can be programmed to have two volume controls. One small practical issue I can see is the visibility of the volume indicators on the AMS dial. Which made me think I might try to put some small markers of some sort.

I just often find myself ranginging by 10 -15dB on various movies / tv shows depending on how they are mastered.

If it was just me using the set-up I would probably be happy enough dealing with it. I'll just have to set up some sort of tutorial / instruction manual for the missus though! She shakes her head at me enough as it is! Or maybe I could get away with just buying her a small transistor radio to use when I'm not home :)

The numbers on the dial of the 35i are impossible to read from any distance....so a homemade arrow made from a yellow "post-it" note pad would do the trick.

My wife is the same; and if its not 5.1 (most of what she watches), she only uses the centre speaker anyway.
 

acalex

New member
Sep 13, 2011
73
0
0
Visit site
CnoEvil said:
acalex said:
My dealer suggested to hear for a few hours at home both amplifier without switching to them and pick up the one that overall it is easier to listen and gives me more listening pleasure. What do you think about this advice?

thanks again

The problem that you have, is that there isn't necessarily an absolute answer, just a compromise. I think what your dealer has said is very wise, and was going to suggest it myself if switching back and forth didn't come up with an answer. Just bear in mind that mood has a lot with how much you enjoy the music and you can reach saturation point after a few hours of intensive listening/analysis.....so have good breaks and let the music "soak in" and see which instinctually gives more pleasure.

I think what I would do is make a long play list (or batch of CDs) made up of an eclectic mix of your best known music.....but batch it in groups ie. Music that sounds worst on the Jadis, music that sounds best on the Jadis and vica versa for the 35i (it may be the same 2 lists, but it also may not).

If I had to guess, I would say that for listening at home with your current kit, I would expect the Jadis will come out on top. The reason for this is that it is more forgiving than the AMS. It will certainly offset the slight forwardness of the speakers, and to some extent, be less revealing of the deficiency of the source.

Provided the synergy remains intact, I would expect the MF to close the gap as the source improves (as it can't honey coat to the same extent) and with speakers like the SF, there is no brightness to offset. There is also the fact that Cardas cabling is famous for its richer musical presentation.

So in summary, sit back, relax (without turning yourself inside out with analysis), and let the decision come to you by Osmosis...but when all is said and done, the acid test will come with the correct TT, speakers and cabling.

Thanks a lot for sharing your view. It is indeed for me impossible to come up with a decision right now at home since as you said correctly, the speakers and the source play a great role. Neverthless, I still prefer jadis on some stuff, but AMS on other staff which I know less but it is for sure more dynamic.

I will indeed try the AMS and the Jadis at the shop with a great phonostage (the same I will be buying) and with a better digital source also. I will book a demo on Friday afternoon to settle this. Hopefully... :)

It is indeed quite a complicated choice for me as I think they are both the best for me of two different worlds (tube and SS), so it is a matter of choice which road I want to follow.

For a change, my gf realised the AMS is a nice amp but she still prefers the Jadis in term of design. She still didn't hear the beast so far :)
 

acalex

New member
Sep 13, 2011
73
0
0
Visit site
oldric_naubhoff said:
acalex said:
In my imagination I see the inpol 2 as a bit in the middle between the powerful ams and the romantic jadis. Having a bit of ams but not as much and a bit of jadis but again not as much.

;)

"It seems that Pathos designers and technicians have achieved the target of obtaining the "mirage of an iron fist in a velvet glove.""

acalex said:
I will try to go out and listen but can't promise anything. Maybe after the mention of official forum taster will be more motivated to do that :), jocking of course. Stay reassured hat if I have an opportunity I will do and share my impressions with you.

appreciated :)

on another topic. it was always puzzling to me how a low power class A can even compete with high power class B or class D. now I know :)

it appears that it's dynamic power that counts. usual power ratings are calculated into sine waves (most likely 1kHz) into stable loads which yields maximum RMS rating, which says nothing about dynamic capabilities of an amp. in order to play music loud you need no more than 2Wpc RMS (sic!). even with moderately inefficient speakers it'll be plenty loud. with efficient speakers you'll need even less. even less than 1Wpc! anyway, the amp has to cater for dynamic peaks in the programme material (music) and that's where dynamic power comes to fore. in case of AMS35i it looks like this:

RMS power: 17V^2/ 8 Ohm = 36Wpc into 8 Ohm load (basically what is speced in the blurb)

dynamic power: 47Vpeak^2/ 8 Ohm = 276Wpc into 8 Ohm load (!)

data taken form MF's brochure for AMS35i. so, as long as those values for voltage delivery are not taken out of the air it means that AMS can easily play very dynamic material loudly in domestic environment without even breaking a sweat (no clipping)! I'm not quite sure about my calculations here but it may suggest dynamic headroom in excess of 24dB! provided you use AMS with suitably efficient speakers - such that will allow you to listen at 1Wpc RMS in your listening position. I'd expect anything around 90dB/1W/1m mark listened at 3m will suffice. that means that even hugely dynamic pieces, like philharmonic works, will be reproduced without clipping. sure it'll be on the edge of AMS's capabilities but does it really matter in the end?

I'd like to add here that I'm not trying to diss any of those horse power amps. if they can play a sine wave at 500Wpc or more into 8 Ohm load they definitely will not falter reproducing music. the thing is; you don't need all that power in your room! this is definitely very relieving info. you can easily go for a dynamic class A amp not worrying it will clip at some stage playing music. and thus you can enjoy the best sound quality (everybody knows class B is a no-go, not to mention class D). the only condition amp's designer has to meet is to equip the amp with a potent power supply (possibly with a large energy reservoir. unfortunately capacitor banks costs money) so it could recharge appropriately fast to be able to deliver enough voltage/ current exactly when asked for.

I thought you guys would like to hear about my recent findings. :)

I only wish I had similar Voltage delivery data for Pathos's amps... but I'd expect them to be very dynamic too. AFAIK power supply makes up bulk of the weight in those +40kg beasts (TT and Inpol2).

regards!

P.S. I think what I just wrote about dynamic power and RMS power requirements is nothing new to you, or it's nothing anybody reasonably thinking wouldn't come up with. but in face of wide spread propaganda that you need at least XXXXX Watts of power in order to fully appreciate listening to music in your home I thought I'd write this post. I also think that those who claim you need kilowatts of power to drive speakers simply don't get it.

Wow, thanks a lot for the beautiful explanation. I indeed saw the specs (17V and 47V) but couldn't explain. So the 17V is the Volt RMS whilst the 47V spec is the peak to peak voltage range which identifies the dynamic range indeed.

Now I see much clearer...I was aware that you don't need KW of power to fill comfortably a decent sized room with sound, now I have the scientific proof and I like it :D! Pity you don't have these type of specs for every amps...would like to understand what's the peak of a tube amp like the Jadis.

The fact that tube amps work usually with higher voltage does not tell us anything regarding its peak to peak voltage?

Thanks again for the excellent explanation
 

CnoEvil

New member
Aug 21, 2009
556
14
0
Visit site
acalex said:
It is indeed for me impossible to come up with a decision right now at home since as you said correctly, the speakers and the source play a great role. Neverthless, I still prefer jadis on some stuff, but AMS on other staff which I know less but it is for sure more dynamic.

ATM What percentage of your music sounds better through the Jadis?

Also, given as a percentage, how close does the MF get to the Jadis (where it excels) vs Jadis to the MF (where it excels)....Not an easy question, I know.
 

acalex

New member
Sep 13, 2011
73
0
0
Visit site
CnoEvil said:
acalex said:
It is indeed for me impossible to come up with a decision right now at home since as you said correctly, the speakers and the source play a great role. Neverthless, I still prefer jadis on some stuff, but AMS on other staff which I know less but it is for sure more dynamic.

ATM What percentage of your music sounds better through the Jadis?

Also, given as a percentage, how close does the MF get to the Jadis (where it excels) vs Jadis to the MF (where it excels)....Not an easy question, I know.

Not easy at all...they both sound so great... :wall:

My gf listened to Ironic from Unplugged album and said it sounds more clean and powerful played on AMS but more emotional on Jadis and she prefers the second version!
 

CnoEvil

New member
Aug 21, 2009
556
14
0
Visit site
acalex said:
Not easy at all...they both sound so great... :wall:

My gf listened to Ironic from Unplugged album and said it sounds more clean and powerful played on AMS but more emotional on Jadis and she prefers the second version!

She needs to be at the final shootout.

I have often found that my wife cuts through all the hi-fi bu11$h!t, and tells it like it is....often very useful when the brain starts over analyzing, and one's pre-conceptions are kicking in!
 

acalex

New member
Sep 13, 2011
73
0
0
Visit site
:shifty:
CnoEvil said:
acalex said:
Not easy at all...they both sound so great... :wall:

My gf listened to Ironic from Unplugged album and said it sounds more clean and powerful played on AMS but more emotional on Jadis and she prefers the second version!

She needs to be at the final shootout.

I have often found that my wife cuts through all the hi-fi bu11$h!t, and tells it like it is....often very useful when the brain starts over analyzing, and one's pre-conceptions are kicking in!

Indeed, this was my face when she told me that :shifty:

She never analysed anything and has been with me at a couple of demo, but that's it!
 

paradiziac

New member
Jan 8, 2011
17
0
0
Visit site
Hmm...why not take them both and switch according to music/mood? :twisted:

My money's on the Jadis... :grin:

Have a listen to track 1. of David Bowie's "Man Who Sold the World", if the Jadis gets your foot tapping in the complicated intro, it's a good sign...
 

acalex

New member
Sep 13, 2011
73
0
0
Visit site
paradiziac said:
Hmm...why not take them both and switch according to music/mood? :twisted:

My money's on the Jadis... :grin:

Have a listen to track 1. of David Bowie's "Man Who Sold the World", if the Jadis gets your foot tapping in the complicated intro, it's a good sign...

Ahaha, I must admit that I thought about it for a second... :shame:

Thanks a lot for the advise, I will listen to it for sure and let you know!
 

Roby

Well-known member
Jan 17, 2012
75
10
18,545
Visit site
acalex said:
paradiziac said:
Hmm...why not take them both and switch according to music/mood? :twisted:

My money's on the Jadis... :grin:

Have a listen to track 1. of David Bowie's "Man Who Sold the World", if the Jadis gets your foot tapping in the complicated intro, it's a good sign...

Ahaha, I must admit that I thought about it for a second... :shame:

Thanks a lot for the advise, I will listen to it for sure and let you know!

If you don't have it I can bringyou the Bowie cd :)
 

acalex

New member
Sep 13, 2011
73
0
0
Visit site
Roby said:
acalex said:
paradiziac said:
Hmm...why not take them both and switch according to music/mood? :twisted:

My money's on the Jadis... :grin:

Have a listen to track 1. of David Bowie's "Man Who Sold the World", if the Jadis gets your foot tapping in the complicated intro, it's a good sign...

Ahaha, I must admit that I thought about it for a second... :shame:

Thanks a lot for the advise, I will listen to it for sure and let you know!

If you don't have it I can bringyou the Bowie cd :)

That's a good idea! The first track is "Width of a Circle", correct?
 

Roby

Well-known member
Jan 17, 2012
75
10
18,545
Visit site
Roby said:
Roby said:
CnoEvil said:
Have you been speaking to Kronos, as I have a lot of faith in both David and Gary?

Not exactly, I was surfing on the website an had chat with some Stacey. I had just a question about the warenty an ended up talking for more than 1h....

Anyway I think I will give theme a call this week it might help me decide if it's worth it...An then I will ask afther David or Gary.

Other question doe's the AMS come with 2 power chord's or do I need to buy one for Belgium?

Cno witch of to shop's shoud I contact?

Cno

Just called the shop spoke with David he was really helpfull (I understand why you're going there now).

The only problem (witch its easy to work arround) is that apparently MF is working with diffent plug's on the amp for the UK so buy a new power chord is not enough apparently y I should change the conector on the ampside aswell.

So told him I need think about it :? it's secound hand an it is still a lot of money fore a kind of blind purchase + I need to contact MF see if they can send me an european conector etc But it's tempting ;-)
 

CnoEvil

New member
Aug 21, 2009
556
14
0
Visit site
Roby said:
Cno

Just called the shop spoke with David he was really helpfull (I understand why you're going there now).

The only problem (witch its easy to work arround) is that apparently MF is working with diffent plug's on the amp for the UK so buy a new power chord is not enough apparently y I should change the conector on the ampside aswell.

So told him I need think about it :? it's secound hand an it is still a lot of money fore a kind of blind purchase + I need to contact MF see if they can send me an european conector etc But it's tempting ;-)

Glad you found them helpful.....I always have.

They're enthusiastic and knowledgeable, and there are very few brands they haven't come across and so are a mine of information.
 

CnoEvil

New member
Aug 21, 2009
556
14
0
Visit site
Roby said:
Cno actualy do you know something about this difference? Im not shure I got that right :?

I'm sorry Roby, but I don't know enough about it. Maybe Acalex has investigated this, and so could be of more use.
 

acalex

New member
Sep 13, 2011
73
0
0
Visit site
Today is the big day...I feel stressed :)

Listening now to the AMS at home...and like it a lot. Whenever I switch to Jadis I also like it a lot :wall:

Roby I guess something has to be changed on the amp site as probably also the connection on the back of the amp is optimised for an UK cable...not sure about that.
 

Neuphonix

New member
Apr 20, 2012
9
0
0
Visit site
Hi Alex,

good luck with your decision, hope you don't have any second thoughts like I have

I picked up my Diablos on Tuesday, mmmmmmm, what a sexy set of speakers >) My neighbours must be loving me!

So I think I'll try & borrow the AMS sometime next week. Really at this stage I don't really think I'll need it for long.

Robi, I could be wrong but I wouldn't think that you would need to swap the socket on the back of the amp? Looks like a standard IEC male socket like any computer, you should just have to get the right lead. Should be female IEC C13 socket to male type C plug (you are in Belgium?). The voltage is the same 240v. Thats why I was looking at importing one from France because we have the same voltage as Europe here in Australia.

Good luck again Alex, I trust the destination will be equally as enjoyable as the journey.
 

Roby

Well-known member
Jan 17, 2012
75
10
18,545
Visit site
Neuphonix said:
Robi, I could be wrong but I wouldn't think that you would need to swap the socket on the back of the amp? Looks like a standard IEC male socket like any computer, you should just have to get the right lead. Should be female IEC C13 socket to male type C plug (you are in Belgium?). The voltage is the same 240v. Thats why I was looking at importing one from France because we have the same voltage as Europe here in Australia.

Good luck again Alex, I trust the destination will be equally as enjoyable as the journey.

Thanks for the info I provably send them a mail I think it might clear thinks out for me. I really missed some thing when he explained it to me by phone :oops: :?
 

Neuphonix

New member
Apr 20, 2012
9
0
0
Visit site
yeah when you have to change voltages, like 100v for the USA, things can get trickey.

But for Europe it is all 240v, so I can't see it being an issue.

One thing about the musical fidelity website, as far as I can see they don't have any link for cotact via email? Strange. They give their phone number so you can call them, but no customer service email.

I might be accused of being pretty lazy here (wouldn't be the first time). But can someone tell me why you can't turn the AMS (or the M6) on/off via the remote? I know it's not that hard to get up and press a button, but come on. If the unit didn't sit in standby & you were actually switching it completely on & off I could sort of understand it. But the unit sits in standby all the time, pretty lame if you ask me. It's not like the remote has all that many functions, volume/input thats about it, why not an on/off!
 

CnoEvil

New member
Aug 21, 2009
556
14
0
Visit site
Neuphonix said:
I might be accused of being pretty lazy here (wouldn't be the first time). But can someone tell me why you can't turn the AMS (or the M6) on/off via the remote? I know it's not that hard to get up and press a button, but come on. If the unit didn't sit in standby & you were actually switching it completely on & off I could sort of understand it. But the unit sits in standby all the time, pretty lame if you ask me. It's not like the remote has all that many functions, volume/input thats about it, why not an on/off!

With regard to the AMS, it is often the case for full Class A amps not to have a standby mode.....as soon as they're switched on, they draw max power from the mains, whether playing or not.

As far as I know, a remote can only ever put a component on standby.....turning off always requires a physical button.

I think once you hear the 35i + Focals at home, it will be there to stay - do report back with your findings!

Cno
 

TRENDING THREADS

Latest posts