DAC comparison

[SeattleChris]

Might be my last post as my midlife crisis system upgrade fiasco must end now. Not sure how significant this one is but thought I'd report my findings.

For streaming Amazon HD, three years ago I first moved from a Soundblaster Xfi Titanium PC sound card to a Schiit Modi DAC and heard a general improvement. Six months later I upgraded to a Schiit Bifrost 2 and heard more improvement in detail, soundstage size & bass heft. This last summer I got a second one for my headphone amp (in a different room), but this one is the newer Bifrost 2/64 which has different chips. Finally tested them against each other in my main system, going back & forth on maybe a dozen songs.

In every case I heard what was expected from reviews: the new Bifrost 2/64 sounds clearer & more detailed and the old Bifrost 2 sounds a little "thick" with midrange and maybe a bit more "full". What I didn't expect is that I can't choose between the two. Every time I thought one was clearly superior, on the next song I felt the other was clearly superior, and back & forth it went. Each individual recording favored one DAC over the other!

I clearly believe DACs make a noticeable difference and feel the Modi to Bifrost upgrade was worthy. However, within a given level of DAC performance there may be no way to anticipate which will sound best in any given situation. Your stereo system components may favor one DAC in general, but the music genre may indicate a different one, and then the individual song recording may indicate a different one yet. My unexpected conclusion is that within a given level of DAC performance there may not be much point in worrying which one you have!

 

[deaver]

Hi, I am interested in your final sentence as I have been mulling over trying a new Dac , the problem for me is that I find it hard to get my head around how a signal from the Dac can change such things as Separation, Bass weight, sound stage etc. Surely the Dac just sends the converted signal to the Amplifier which then does its thing then sends it to the Speakers which then do their thing as regards Sound stage etc. As I say I struggle to see how the Dac can change what the Amp and Speakers are putting out. I would love someone to explain it to me as I have a 10 year old Arcam IrDac which is very well made , but could I be missing out on improving my system. Maybe!!

 

[nopiano]

Might be my last post as my midlife crisis system upgrade fiasco must end now. Not sure how significant this one is but thought I'd report my findings.

For streaming Amazon HD, three years ago I first moved from a Soundblaster Xfi Titanium PC sound card to a Schiit Modi DAC and heard a general improvement. Six months later I upgraded to a Schiit Bifrost 2 and heard more improvement in detail, soundstage size & bass heft. This last summer I got a second one for my headphone amp (in a different room), but this one is the newer Bifrost 2/64 which has different chips. Finally tested them against each other in my main system, going back & forth on maybe a dozen songs.

In every case I heard what was expected from reviews: the new Bifrost 2/64 sounds clearer & more detailed and the old Bifrost 2 sounds a little "thick" with midrange and maybe a bit more "full". What I didn't expect is that I can't choose between the two. Every time I thought one was clearly superior, on the next song I felt the other was clearly superior, and back & forth it went. Each individual recording favored one DAC over the other!

I clearly believe DACs make a noticeable difference and feel the Modi to Bifrost upgrade was worthy. However, within a given level of DAC performance there may be no way to anticipate which will sound best in any given situation. Your stereo system components may favor one DAC in general, but the music genre may indicate a different one, and then the individual song recording may indicate a different one yet. My unexpected conclusion is that within a given level of DAC performance there may not be much point in worrying which one you have!

I don’t doubt for a second what you believe you heard. Unfortunately, it’s almost impossible to exclude the expectations we have when connecting a new piece of kit.

I’ve been listening to hifi for over fifty years now, and fifteen of those I spent each Saturday working at a Hifi shop where I heard probably hundreds of amps and speakers, never mind cartridges and CD players. However, I find listening to the gear and listening to music in the ordinary way to be quite different, try as I might not to!

That’s why longer-term listening is helpful, rather than the quick switch we do when swapping. Your experience is what often happens - you can’t reliably tell one from t’other, and if you can the levels are probably different enough to be audible.

I can’t really advocate true blind testing as it’s too complex, but not knowing what’s playing can give surprising results. DACs are probably the least likely product to reveal meaningful differences, given that technically even the simplest DAC has pretty much all the usual distortions and noises at an inaudibly low level. Nevertheless, many will claim night and day improvements, and if that makes them happy then that’s great!

 

[SeattleChris]

Hi, I am interested in your final sentence as I have been mulling over trying a new Dac , the problem for me is that I find it hard to get my head around how a signal from the Dac can change such things as Separation, Bass weight, sound stage etc. Surely the Dac just sends the converted signal to the Amplifier which then does its thing then sends it to the Speakers which then do their thing as regards Sound stage etc. As I say I struggle to see how the Dac can change what the Amp and Speakers are putting out. I would love someone to explain it to me as I have a 10 year old Arcam IrDac which is very well made , but could I be missing out on improving my system. Maybe!!

Hi deaver - Lots of debate here as to how much different DACs affect sound, or if they even can. As nopiano suggested, expectations affect our perception so comparisons are difficult as few of us manage to do them blind. I try to keep that in mind, second guessing (and third and forth guessing) whether I'm really hearing what I think I am.

I feel my Bifrost 2/64 vs Bifrost 2 test has some validity because while I heard exactly what I expected on every song, that didn't mean one was better over-all. It was split pretty evenly, half the songs sounded better with the 2/64's clearer, more detailed presentation and half sounded better with the 2's more "full" presentation (even if not as clear & detailed). If each individual recording favors one DAC over the other there's no point in worrying about which one I'm using. However, I'm confident both Bifrosts sound better than the Modi, but at several times the price you would sure hope so (and is that why I think so?). I'm afraid all you can do is see for yourself if you're able...

 

[Gray]

Based on my limited DAC experience, I can't imagine differences ever really being anything more than subtle.
Subtle enough to make blind comparisons difficult, if not impossible.
Can you imagine saying that about speaker comparisons?

When it comes to improving sound, DACs must be well down the list of things to change, virtually non-existent on the "bang for buck" spectrum.

 

[abacus]

Hi, I am interested in your final sentence as I have been mulling over trying a new Dac , the problem for me is that I find it hard to get my head around how a signal from the Dac can change such things as Separation, Bass weight, sound stage etc. Surely the Dac just sends the converted signal to the Amplifier which then does its thing then sends it to the Speakers which then do their thing as regards Sound stage etc. As I say I struggle to see how the Dac can change what the Amp and Speakers are putting out. I would love someone to explain it to me as I have a 10 year old Arcam IrDac which is very well made , but could I be missing out on improving my system. Maybe!!

Assuming it's a good quality DAC then the associated components and circuit design makes the biggest difference, however it is not going to be a big difference but will be noticeable (Usually lower noise and distortion etc.) depending on the quality of the rest of the equipment it is feeding.

Bill