mr malarky said:Ontheline, if your still not convinced then here's a simple test - you've probably got an HD TV? If so then it will have a video scaler built in. If upscaling gives the same quality as HD source material then you should see no difference flicking between BBC1 and BBC1HD; so start watching a programme and then switch between the two channels every few minutes, and see if you can see a difference. Have a go and see what you think?
That's a test that I often do to show people how much better BBC1 HD is than ordinary standard definition BBC1. Excellent reasoning, Mr Malarky!