Last year i have listen to many speakers. Good speakers, but none of them are suitable for metal. For metal you need good bass (also not small woofers), warm midrange and sweet treble. Also dynamic and not too transparant. Those speakers are not more. Nowadays speakers are too transparant and with too hot treble. Vintage is the only solution.
There are no hifi speakers for metal
- Thread starter peterpan
- Start date
bigfish786
Moderator
- Jan 29, 2013
- 883
- 789
- 19,770
peterpan said:
metal is like every other genre of music, no speaker company sells their product as a genre specific speaker.
Blacksabbath25
Well-known member
- Sep 20, 2015
- 309
- 88
- 18,970
What speakers have you tried....and on the end of what amps (which are important as well)?
Which combination got cloesest to what you are looking for?
Which combination got cloesest to what you are looking for?
chris_bates1974
Well-known member
- Feb 28, 2013
- 96
- 37
- 10,570
According to my definition of transparent - where it sounds as if the music is not coming from speakers but from actual musicians in your room - then the more transparent the better.peterpan said:
If you're talking about speakers that are marketed as transparent, when the reality is that they have a hump in the midrange of the frequency response to create the psycho-acoustic impression of transparancy then yes, I totally agree.
I totally agree about needing good quality big woofers and dynamic sounding speakers for metal.
Totally agree that the vast majority of modern speakers are too dynamically compressed and are too small.
Peterpan, you may find this interesting reading: https://www.audioasylum.com/cgi/vt.mpl?f=hug&m=178426
I agree with Claudej1; 8" or smaller woofers don't cut the mustard.
Vladimir said:
but my two first choice, go to albums that I know and have used consistently to see how new speakers sound and new component intergrate are Machine Head's - Burn My Eyes and Sepultura's - Roots. I'm not suggesting they're are reference standard but to me they are, my reference point.
Vladimir, what, like Nirvana Nevermind?
Or Iron Maiden Fear of the Dark?
On a poor system these albums can be headache inducing noise. On a good system you're listening to an accomplished set of songwriters and musicians making engrossing music with emotional impact.
Or Iron Maiden Fear of the Dark?
On a poor system these albums can be headache inducing noise. On a good system you're listening to an accomplished set of songwriters and musicians making engrossing music with emotional impact.
lindsayt said:
Nirvana doesn't fall in the metal genre AFAIK.
I'm asking because I'd like to give them a listen on my speakers.
I think Nevermind by Nirvana is probably a good album to judge a heavy rock system.
It's not quite metal in the way slayer or sepultura are metal, but it's thick dense music that demands from a system. I actually don't enjoy Nevermind on Spotify at all, I love Spotify but find some heavy albums are lacking there
It's not quite metal in the way slayer or sepultura are metal, but it's thick dense music that demands from a system. I actually don't enjoy Nevermind on Spotify at all, I love Spotify but find some heavy albums are lacking there
muljao said:
Grunge, Punk rock, Alternative rock
Genres vary so much by different decade. Both Kiss and Darkthrone fall under same genre.
plastic penguin
Well-known member
- Apr 28, 2008
- 6,539
- 3,153
- 36,570
peterpan said:
Years ago, seem to remember WHFI testing Nad 356 with Quad L11s, and I think it had rave reviews for the balance of the combo. Not sure if the floorstanding version of the Quads are still available.
I've tried looking in my archive of WHFI mags, but most are in the attic.
plastic penguin
Well-known member
- Apr 28, 2008
- 6,539
- 3,153
- 36,570
Oh yes it does, but as the OP says, it's a lot easier to find at a real world price in vintage speakers than modern.plastic penguin said:
It's all about the bass and the dynamics.
Is Grunge not a sub-genre of metal, both of which are sub-genres of rock - which my grandad would have called sub-genres of jazz?Vladimir said:
Do these classifications matter?
Blacksabbath25
Well-known member
- Sep 20, 2015
- 309
- 88
- 18,970
onslaught album In search of sanity .... Track 1 Asylum on some speakers this track will distort a speaker
Gun's & Roses .... Use your illusion 2 ... Track 16 Coma .... same here can make a speaker distort with the bass driver
iced Earth...... plagues of Babylon ..... Track 1 .. plagues of Babylon
Metallica.... Black Album..... Track .... 12 ... The struggle within
For heavy Metal or thrash metal you need Floor standing speakers to get the best out of this type of music as stand mounted speakers just do not cut it with this kind of music .
the cabinet size matters as your need to push lots of air
driver size matters nice large drivers for good low down bass
and finally you need a good amplifier that will be boss over those speakers a specially with bass control .
Gun's & Roses .... Use your illusion 2 ... Track 16 Coma .... same here can make a speaker distort with the bass driver
iced Earth...... plagues of Babylon ..... Track 1 .. plagues of Babylon
Metallica.... Black Album..... Track .... 12 ... The struggle within
For heavy Metal or thrash metal you need Floor standing speakers to get the best out of this type of music as stand mounted speakers just do not cut it with this kind of music .
the cabinet size matters as your need to push lots of air
driver size matters nice large drivers for good low down bass
and finally you need a good amplifier that will be boss over those speakers a specially with bass control .
Facebook
Twitter
Instagram