I'm genuinely pleased for the HD DVD owners who are keeping a positive face!
I hope your players last a long time, as when it breaks down and there's no support and no replacement players your HD DVD library is a useless. Maybe buying an HD DVD player post Warner Brothers statement in January won't appear to be such a good idea!
I have sympathy with this as I did amass a large LaserDisc library, over 200 discs between 1988 and 1998! I do at least have a working player (Pioneer CLD-D925) with two other Pioneer players (CLD-3070 NTSC) and (CLD-1450 PAL) as boxed back-ups!
It's also possible that some of the HD DVD titles may never get released on Blu-ray? Poor sales of some discs may mean that the studios may not wish to get their fingers burned a second time!
The profile 1.0, 1.1, 2.0 issue is largely a side show! The most important issues are picture and sound quality. Most people only buy the single DVD editions, if you look at the sales charts!
At least Cars (US WB version) and Rush Hour 3 (UK New Line/EIV) have picture in picture and they should work on ALL Blu-ray players! Who needs profile 1.1? I'm sure there are others?
Profile 2.0 - different issue altogether. This could encourage the studios to deliberately omit desirable material from discs, in order to get more of your money!? It's the tip of the iceburg! And then there's the big brother angle. Some may already object to digital TV knowing what you watch and when. Now the studios and others will know what you buy to watch - not an issue for some, but there are possibilities that need to be debated.
Question for those who have purchased HD DVD players recently. Are they multi region for regular DVDs?
There have been many recommendations for their upscaling abilities. Fine, but if you need another one for DVD player for NTSC DVDs, then what's the point? You could end up with three players, DVD (Multi Region/DVD-Audio/SACD), HD DVD and Blu-ray!
I'm sure there will be Blu-ray players with multi-region standard DVD playback.