This statement is complete nonsense. The sound quality produced by an old HMV Vinyl Vintage Gramophone and the sound quality produced by a new and modern system will be like chalk and cheese. I can't believe some people think their low fi needs or expectations are all anybody should be looking for. Utter tripe. If people can't appreciate HIFI music reproduction, or don't need it, they shouldn't be posting these sorts of comments on a HIFI forum.
I have decent hearing and I'm very discerning and can fully appreciate and enjoy my music. The effort that goes into music recordings, by any self respecting artist or band, is done for a reason. You don't see musicians using the worst quality kit, with a 'that'll do' attitude, because many people don't care about music, or its faithful reproduction.
I remember many years ago seeing a bloke running a market stall and he had BBC Radio 1 NEARLY tuned in. This station has always played dreadful music anyway, but not tuned in properly made it sound like bacon being fried. He wasn't concerned and I think he turned up the volume. These are the idiots that I complain about. They can't appreciate music, culture, quality, nice food or anything more than basic human functions. We've evolved into a very perceptive species and although human hearing has its limits, people today are exposed to much higher fidelity music and as a result get more from their passion, as I do.
HIFI really is like wine. There's good and bad. Some people say they like wine, because they are pretentious, and struggle to drink even the good stuff and many people turn into wine snobs. I can tell the good from the bad, because I've exposed my palate to many bottles over the years and I prefer the better ones. It makes sense really, but liking good wine over plonk doesn't make me a snob, it just makes me discerning and appreciate good from bad. People who can't tell good from bad shouldn't tell others there's no difference.
Labouring the metaphor even further, there is a finite amount of stuff in a grape and the drink it produces and you literally cannot squeeze out anything more. HIFI does reflect this and although there's a spectrum of pleasure and quality, there is also a finite amount of information you can 'squeeze' out of electronics. There is a law of diminishing returns and spending huge amounts is just wasteful.
I will guarantee listening to The Carpenters on CD will be so close to the original recording. When Karen was singing back in the 70s, there is NO CHANCE AT ALL, your car radio, record player, or any other consumer gadget would have giving anything but a poor approximation. We are so lucky these days, having NEARLY studio quality music playback. I get derided on here saying CD sounds better than the ancient LP records, but it does. If you don't like better sound quality and just want to play around with tracking weights and other nonsense, then I don't want you to stop doing that. The vinyl revival doesn't mean this format suddenly has a new and improved sound, because it can't and it doesn't.