chebby said:
There is many a hi-fi component/system that I couldn't stand the sound of.
Many people here express dislike for many products (and their manufacturers) on a regular basis. They frequently use words like 'hate' (or worse) and yet, it only ever seems to be an issue when an AVI product is involved.
Why is it that someone can criticise Naim or Arcam or Linn or Panasonic (or whoever) in the strongest terms but, when it comes to AVI, everyone has to tread on eggshells or face a multi-pronged attack from members of the AVI forum?
I have frequently criticised Naim, Arcam (and even Rega) on points as various as their sound to things like their looks or some of the nonsense their manufacturers come out with regarding cable direction or warm up times (for instance).
I have never got 'jumped on' in the way that would - inevitably - happen if I criticised AVI.
I am not about to criticise AVI products on any grounds of sound, build or quality because I have not personally experienced them. Sometimes I have been known to suggest trying them to people as a possible solution. I trust that they are as good as the reviews and their users - here and elsewhere - say they are. I don't have any doubts that they are a high quality product.
But what is so special about AVI, in particular, that they are beyond criticism in a way that other manufacturers aren't?
Chebby, I will have a go at addressing the above from my perspective.
AVI owners, and others, see a question or statement from an OP and where that individual believes that the recommendation or discussion of AVI products is relevant they make their contribution. Other people do the same thing in relation to other products. Some people make no effort to make any suggestions about matters relevant to the OP, they just slag-off AVI.
To take this thread as an example, the OP asked this, "Does anyone have or heard how loud AVI ADM9.1 go?". People who DO actually own them or at least have heard them tell the OP their experience, just like I did. The thread is then taken off down a cul-de-sac of whether there are or are not reliable verifyable measurements of loudness by AVI and other manufacturers, which is not relevant to this OP.
The OP wants to know from people about what they have heard, he will want to listen to them not measure them.
AVI products and AVI itself is not beyond criticism, we hear it all the time from some people. If I were not experienced in the abilities etc of AVI products I would have to ask myself why owners are so passionate about them. Most owners, just like me, have had many many years of alternative products and in our EXPERIENCE AVI is SO significantly better than what we have owned and heard before that we try to let other people in on the secret or answer their questions directly. I have no problem at all with people liking other things, but there is no need to slag stuff off particularly if you haven't ever heard it.
Ben has made a comment about the AVI sub. When I started writing this inadequate piece no-one had jumped on him and won't because he is making a comment based on his experience. No problem with anyone saying they don't like something from AVI when it is an informed opinion not almost hysterical antiness. I could interfere in all sorts of threads slagging off products based on a quick listen or even a demo but all I do is relate my experience from an ongoing ownership perspective. My contribution is to inform people about a less well known way of listening because it was revelatory to me and it might just do someone else a good turn, save them money, make them a little happier. I don't think that is something to be criticised for.
So criticise away if anyone wants to, but make it relevant to the Thread and if possible make it from a position of real knowlege/experience not hatred or deliberate spoiling.
I have read this now and it is a poor and [very] long-winded reply to a very reasonable[and reasonably put] question, but I started and now I have finished.
:cheer: