Jim_W
New member
I didn't expect a reply!! Why is looking forward to better/easier times the worst of all?! The rest I can identify with; I'm sure that's just about the story of life in the UK in a pretty succint nutshell.
Jim_W said:Why is looking forward to better/easier times the worst of all?!
Freddy58 said:Jim_W said:Why is looking forward to better/easier times the worst of all?!
Because you lose sight of what you have.
BIGBERNARDBRESSLAW said:John Coltrane - Sun Ship
Finally picked it up today from my Dad.
thescarletpronster said:BIGBERNARDBRESSLAW said:John Coltrane - Sun Ship
Finally picked it up today from my Dad.
And...? What did you think of it? It's an album I don't know, and I'm interested.
BIGBERNARDBRESSLAW said:I would say it varies from very avantgarde, to relatively tuneul and melodic, though it never gets anything remotely like easy listening, the drummer makes sure of that.
I own 'Coltrane Jazz' and 'Blue Train', and it's a lot further 'out there' than those two.
Jim_W said:Freddy58 said:Jim_W said:Why is looking forward to better/easier times the worst of all?!
Because you lose sight of what you have.
...thought that's what you meant. It's understandable/normal to look ahead I guess, but I never did as I'm a bit disorganised and it took me all my time to concentrate on the here and now. Like retiring...I had no idea I was old enough...I thought it was for older people...in my head I was still 25. It came as a big shock....and it often still is. I need a job!!
Lost Angeles said:Jim_W said:Freddy58 said:Jim_W said:Why is looking forward to better/easier times the worst of all?!
Because you lose sight of what you have.
...thought that's what you meant. It's understandable/normal to look ahead I guess, but I never did as I'm a bit disorganised and it took me all my time to concentrate on the here and now. Like retiring...I had no idea I was old enough...I thought it was for older people...in my head I was still 25. It came as a big shock....and it often still is. I need a job!!
No you don't, works for the young. The warmer days are coming. What you need are perhaps a few interests. Remember the trouble with retirement is you never get a day off.*dance4*
Cheers.Jim_W said:Lost Angeles said:Jim_W said:Freddy58 said:Jim_W said:Why is looking forward to better/easier times the worst of all?!
Because you lose sight of what you have.
...thought that's what you meant. It's understandable/normal to look ahead I guess, but I never did as I'm a bit disorganised and it took me all my time to concentrate on the here and now. Like retiring...I had no idea I was old enough...I thought it was for older people...in my head I was still 25. It came as a big shock....and it often still is. I need a job!!
No you don't, works for the young. The warmer days are coming. What you need are perhaps a few interests. Remember the trouble with retirement is you never get a day off.*dance4*
This made me laugh, LA! You're right of course, the winter is a drag and the warmer days will be here soon and everything will start to look better. Good advice...ty.
Jim_W said:Just as Parker freed jazz from traditional harmonic and rhythmic norms, so Coltane was doing the same for melody and rhythm: a freer metre and rhythms that were implied rather than stated. BBB's comment re Elvin Jones' drums was probably one the reasons why Coltrane disbanded the great quartet after these sessions: he was seeking more rhythmic flexibility and maybe he felt those thunderous drums were not what he wanted. Alice Coltrane replaced McCoy Tyner on piano and her eerie chords also helped free him. This is jazz academy stuff and musical theory and it's pretty interesting but this isn't the place to go into it.
More important is why did Coltrane want a freer and perhaps more pure form of expression? The sixties was a time of massive change and all well-documented re the growth of spirituality, Eastern influences, black Civil Rights etc which, in itself, would form the basis of some very long essays. You could argue that everything, or many things, came together to facilitate musicians expressing themselves more directly, for example the honks and shrieks of the avant-garde mid 1960's black jazz musician were often interpreted as angry outpourings of a repressed minority and a cry for equality etc cf Archie Shepp, Albert Ayler and the great Pharoah Sanders. More importantly, it was their unique voice and I guess was designed to be alienating...that's part of their experience. However, Coltrane used the avant -garde and the freedom it gave him to express, in my opinion, his own inner battles and personal longing for spiritual enlightenment. So, like a poet wouldn't use rhyme which suggests an ordered and hamonious world, the saxophonists used broken, harsh and angular phrases to express troubled inner feelings and responses. Coltrane playing in this mode is often beautiful as there's a yearning quality which moves, through painful expression, towards harmonious resolution and enlightenment. 'Stellar Regions' is a good example.
For a brilliant insight into how Coltrane felt his quartet could not give him the flexibility he needed to express himself and how 'Sun Ship 'was just about as much as he could achieve with this band, listen to 'First Meditations' with the quartet and then 'Meditations' with Pharoah Sanders, Alice Coltrane and Rashied Ali. It all becomes very clear what he wanted. 'First Meditations' is just wonderful, but it isn't really 'out there' whereas 'Meditations' is more complex and difficult and certainly much freer.
You could write books on the cultural significance of the 60's and many people have done; these ramblings were just some pointers.
BIGBERNARDBRESSLAW said:Jim_W said:Just as Parker freed jazz from traditional harmonic and rhythmic norms, so Coltane was doing the same for melody and rhythm: a freer metre and rhythms that were implied rather than stated. BBB's comment re Elvin Jones' drums was probably one the reasons why Coltrane disbanded the great quartet after these sessions: he was seeking more rhythmic flexibility and maybe he felt those thunderous drums were not what he wanted. Alice Coltrane replaced McCoy Tyner on piano and her eerie chords also helped free him. This is jazz academy stuff and musical theory and it's pretty interesting but this isn't the place to go into it.
More important is why did Coltrane want a freer and perhaps more pure form of expression? The sixties was a time of massive change and all well-documented re the growth of spirituality, Eastern influences, black Civil Rights etc which, in itself, would form the basis of some very long essays. You could argue that everything, or many things, came together to facilitate musicians expressing themselves more directly, for example the honks and shrieks of the avant-garde mid 1960's black jazz musician were often interpreted as angry outpourings of a repressed minority and a cry for equality etc cf Archie Shepp, Albert Ayler and the great Pharoah Sanders. More importantly, it was their unique voice and I guess was designed to be alienating...that's part of their experience. However, Coltrane used the avant -garde and the freedom it gave him to express, in my opinion, his own inner battles and personal longing for spiritual enlightenment. So, like a poet wouldn't use rhyme which suggests an ordered and hamonious world, the saxophonists used broken, harsh and angular phrases to express troubled inner feelings and responses. Coltrane playing in this mode is often beautiful as there's a yearning quality which moves, through painful expression, towards harmonious resolution and enlightenment. 'Stellar Regions' is a good example.
For a brilliant insight into how Coltrane felt his quartet could not give him the flexibility he needed to express himself and how 'Sun Ship 'was just about as much as he could achieve with this band, listen to 'First Meditations' with the quartet and then 'Meditations' with Pharoah Sanders, Alice Coltrane and Rashied Ali. It all becomes very clear what he wanted. 'First Meditations' is just wonderful, but it isn't really 'out there' whereas 'Meditations' is more complex and difficult and certainly much freer.
You could write books on the cultural significance of the 60's and many people have done; these ramblings were just some pointers.
Thanks Jim, but I thought I'd covered all that in my post. *biggrin*
Jim_W said:Just as Parker freed jazz from traditional harmonic and rhythmic norms, so Coltane was doing the same for melody and rhythm: a freer metre and rhythms that were implied rather than stated. BBB's comment re Elvin Jones' drums was probably one the reasons why Coltrane disbanded the great quartet after these sessions: he was seeking more rhythmic flexibility and maybe he felt those thunderous drums were not what he wanted. Alice Coltrane replaced McCoy Tyner on piano and her eerie chords also helped free him. This is jazz academy stuff and musical theory and it's pretty interesting but this isn't the place to go into it.
More important is why did Coltrane want a freer and perhaps more pure form of expression? The sixties was a time of massive change and all well-documented re the growth of spirituality, Eastern influences, black Civil Rights etc which, in itself, would form the basis of some very long essays. You could argue that everything, or many things, came together to facilitate musicians expressing themselves more directly, for example the honks and shrieks of the avant-garde mid 1960's black jazz musician were often interpreted as angry outpourings of a repressed minority and a cry for equality etc cf Archie Shepp, Albert Ayler and the great Pharoah Sanders. More importantly, it was their unique voice and I guess was designed to be alienating...that's part of their experience. However, Coltrane used the avant -garde and the freedom it gave him to express, in my opinion, his own inner battles and personal longing for spiritual enlightenment. So, like a poet wouldn't use rhyme which suggests an ordered and hamonious world, the saxophonists used broken, harsh and angular phrases to express troubled inner feelings and responses. Coltrane playing in this mode is often beautiful as there's a yearning quality which moves, through painful expression, towards harmonious resolution and enlightenment. 'Stellar Regions' is a good example.
For a brilliant insight into how Coltrane felt his quartet could not give him the flexibility he needed to express himself and how 'Sun Ship 'was just about as much as he could achieve with this band, listen to 'First Meditations' with the quartet and then 'Meditations' with Pharoah Sanders, Alice Coltrane and Rashied Ali. It all becomes very clear what he wanted. 'First Meditations' is just wonderful, but it isn't really 'out there' whereas 'Meditations' is more complex and difficult and certainly much freer.
You could write books on the cultural significance of the 60's and many people have done; these ramblings were just some pointers.
Jim_W said:BIGBERNARDBRESSLAW said:Thanks Jim, but I thought I'd covered all that in my post. *biggrin*
Yeah you did; I just had some time on my hands and expanded a couple of points. Really though, your original comments contained the essential stuff. I just like being pretentious. *biggrin*
BIGBERNARDBRESSLAW said:Jim_W said:BIGBERNARDBRESSLAW said:Thanks Jim, but I thought I'd covered all that in my post. *biggrin*
Yeah you did; I just had some time on my hands and expanded a couple of points. Really though, your original comments contained the essential stuff. I just like being pretentious. *biggrin*
Not at all, and to be serious for a second. I like to educate about music, and I like being educated about music, and whenever you write about music it's usually an education for me.
Jim_W said:You're too kind, BBB...I'm just so wrapped up in music it's silly really. If you sort of liked 'Sun Ship' though I really do recommend 'First Meditations' ; it's like 'Sun Ship' with much better tunes. Just much more engaging. One of my very favourite records to be honest.
BIGBERNARDBRESSLAW said:Jim_W said:You're too kind, BBB...I'm just so wrapped up in music it's silly really. If you sort of liked 'Sun Ship' though I really do recommend 'First Meditations' ; it's like 'Sun Ship' with much better tunes. Just much more engaging. One of my very favourite records to be honest.
I more than 'sort of liked' it, Jim, I really liked it, and particularly the madness of the opening track. I know I've expressed before about not liking frantic saxophone, but there's something about Coltrane's (occasional) frantic playing that sets it apart from the rest, and I like it.
'First Meditations' will be added to my enormous list of albums I'd like to own.
Incidentally, have you heard, and do you like the the Laurie Anderson album 'Big Science'?
Jim_W said:Yes, I had a girlfriend who played it constantly! I thought it was a good record and used to enjoy it. No idea what I'd make of it now though. If I see it on my travels tomorrow and it's cheap I'll get hold of a copy.
Jim_W said:It will remind me of a very interesting affair! Now I could really write some stuff about that for your entertainment!
Jim_W said:Coltrane's playing IS different because he's always going somewhere...it's a quest through music and as a listener, I think you sense this. This is not random wild slashing, but wild slashing with an almighty purpose! Youtube 'Love' from 'First Meditations'...listen as he tries to get somewhere...wonderful stuff.
BIGBERNARDBRESSLAW said:Off to the auction to see more records, get excited, only to be hugely disappointed tomorrow when the bidding ends.