Harbeth, I believe Alan Shaw tunes his speakers to his granddaughters voice, this of course could just be marketing.Hi.Fi I have been know= Best System for show you quallity of voices
Difficult with a huge amount of classical work: symphonies, ensembles, concertos etc,Hi.Fi I have been know= Best System for show you quallity of voices
Having demoed Harbeth P3s, they are very good with vocals. Bear in mind any speaker can translate vocal realism, depending on amplification.Harbeth, I believe Alan Shaw tunes his speakers to his granddaughters voice, this of course could just be marketing.
It's what we're evolved to listen for, I watched/listened to "Springsteen on Broadway" earlier. I think its really well recorded his speaking voice and playing guitar. Of course it get over self indulgent but the first 20 mins are okayHaving demoed Harbeth P3s, they are very good with vocals. Bear in mind any speaker can translate vocal realism, depending on amplification.
What?? His Granddaughter's voice?Harbeth, I believe Alan Shaw tunes his speakers to his granddaughters voice, this of course could just be marketing.
Not so strange as it seems John.What?? His Granddaughter's voice?
That's gonna be great for Bass, Drums, a full Orchestra etc. I'm afraid that one's lost on me.
Ah ha, thanks for that. Do they use other tones and sounds when tuning speakers in addition to human voices. Like a range of different kinds of sounds I wonder.Not so strange as it seems John.
As humans, we're especially tuned to every aspect of voice quality.
If a speaker can't reproduce voices accurately, then it's off to a bad start when it comes to any other sounds.
No good using his own voice, because he doesn't know the true sound - using the voice of someone you know well -is probably as good a test as you can give a speaker when it comes to accuracy👍
They ought to.Ah ha, thanks for that. Do they use other tones and sounds when tuning speakers in addition to human voices. Like a range of different kinds of sounds I wonder.
I believe that the sound of a piano is a good test as it is difficult to reproduce the tone of the piano and it is an instrument with a wider frequency range than most instruments.Ah ha, thanks for that. Do they use other tones and sounds when tuning speakers in addition to human voices. Like a range of different kinds of sounds I wonder.
It's a stupid question that salespeople ask when they want to take as much money from a customer as possible. You need to choose audio components according to the principle of "necessary and sufficient" for a particular room and the specific wishes of the userHow much money are you intending to spend?
I heard this decades ago that a piano is a good way to test realism. @matthewpianist would know more about this as he's a good keyboard player.I believe that the sound of a piano is a good test as it is difficult to reproduce the tone of the piano and it is an instrument with a wider frequency range than most instruments.
I would tend to agree in that any speaker that cannot do justice to any human voice and make a stab at accurate rendition of a piano piece isn't going to be able to do justice to anything else....Not so strange as it seems John.
As humans, we're especially tuned to every aspect of voice quality.
If a speaker can't reproduce voices accurately, then it's off to a bad start when it comes to any other sounds.
No good using his own voice, because he doesn't know the true sound - using the voice of someone you know well -is probably as good a test as you can give a speaker when it comes to accuracy👍
You beat me to it.I listen to a lot of different Piano Concertos. I've noticed that pianos seem to really show the accuracy and musicality of speakers.
Oh excellent, I'm glad I'm not talking nonsense then, because I'm pretty sure that you're a guy who knows what he's talking about.👍🏻You beat me to it.
My reference when comparing speakers is anything that features a grand piano ....
Absolutely. They aren’t too hard to encounter in real life, they have lots of overtones, huge dynamic range, a wide frequency range, and sundry associated noises from fingers on keys, pedals, and often the stage. And of course need no amplifiers to be played, so we have an unamplified reference point.I listen to a lot of different Piano Concertos. I've noticed that pianos seem to really show the accuracy and musicality of speakers.