Q Acoustics BT3 Review
Equipment:
Source 16bit 44.1KHz FLAC files stored on computer.
DAC - Meridian Explorer
Cable - standard £2 3.5mm jack to phono RCA.
A smooth DAC and a not-pacey pair of BT3. I think I prefer faster audio kit, but anyway.... this is what I think.
Impressions No offensive buzzing when there is no music playing.
Even after being allowed to burn-in over for four days, they still seemed to have been softening in sound. Initially they were cold sounding and had a very small sound stage; both aspects of which changed. I absolutely hear my Meridian Explorer signature in them. I hear the same sort of slight congestion when the going gets tough.
In every way though my Grado SR225e seemed to be faster and more detailed. These headphones could comfortably pause and take a breath while the BT3 are doing their best. That doesn't mean that the SR225e had it all their own way though. The BT3 get close to the SR225e sometimes. Also because of the new presentation I hear details I missed in my headphones. The details are there in the headphones, but overlooked because other sounds are more forward.
An area where the 225e were winning was in bass response. Given the Grado Prestige Series are reputed as not bass heavy, this isn't good. This may be the fault of my cheap 3.5mm jack to RCA though. I can't confirm this until I buy a quality cable. However doing a little equalising and the BT3 make more sense. My music player allows me to EQ at 31HZ and 62Hz at the lower end. 31Hz had zero effect, meaning the BT3 have zero response at that frequency. However increasing just 3dB at 62Hz and the BT3 had a new lease of life. The lower sounds were all warmer and the overall signature seems normal.
I have settled with increasing 3dB at 50Hz in the Windows Control Panel thus eq-ing all sound from my PC. I had not forseen this bass lightness and to be honest the bass is quite weak without EQ. If this is the natural performance and not cable related, adding a source without EQ would be affected. For music at near field, close up the music sounds good. They do fit the the function of desktop speakers. It took a while to adjust to them though.
Techno sounds surpisingly a little warm and pristine. Testing with Bellisima (DJ Quicksilver) and Seven Days One week (B.B.E.). There's a solidity and punch. Fading Like a Flower (Dancing DJs vs Roxette) fills your ears and messes with air pressure, which is good!
Abba Gold sounded a little digital and harsh sounding on my headphones. Sounds fairly normal on BT3. The best of Lang Lang pretty good representation. However lacking some bite.
The Best of Sade - Smooth jazz, which needs more clarity in the purcussive taps.
Hawkwind - Brainstorm (from Doremi Fasol Latido album) sounded much as I hoped. It was a little slow in timing and could have used more clarity but the album conveyed well.
PC Gaming For this use they are good speakers. Initially I much preferred my headhones. However after a couple of days burning-in I moved to the BT3 most of the time. I found it a more relaxing way to hear audio in games. They produce an audio experience which fills all available space in front so allowing for immersion. Only when absolute directional information of enemy placement is necessary will the headphones be better. I played through Crysis 3 and the BT3 were totally on form. The only thing I missed was rain sounds coming from behind which headphones do. However good interconnect does help with that, so I need to get one.
Watching DVD Again they do really well for this job. Watching content is easier with speakers that with headphones. It's because I am not constantly aware movement is restricted and I can relax more. Sound is immersive and takes you closer to the movie.
Upgrades. A quality 3.5mm jack to RCA (Hopefully this would fill out the bass, and increase speed and detail.) All reviews of five-star cables claim better detail so I am going to buy one. A quality length of speaker cable between the master and slave speaker should also make a good upgrade.
Final Impressions. I think the better deal was the Onkyo A9010 and the Q Acoustics 3020 currently on Richer Sounds at £315. It would have been my choice if two aspects had not changed my mind. I have no space for the amplifier. The 3020 are best 15cm from a rear wall and that moves the speakers forward. They would have been too close to the user on desktop.
I expected more from the BT3. However I think I can not expect too much given the weak interconnect between DAC and BT3. I know from experience that good quality cables make all the difference. A cable described as being fast and detailed would be ideal. Neither is the DAC really of exceptional quality. Having said this the BT3 are good speakers. The ground work is done, meaning with the weak cable, they are a reasonable package.
If a new 3.5mm to RCA cable adds the missing bass, then they will be great. However if not then the BT3 for me do not operate without EQ. They are too bass light and not a complete package.
At the moment they also have a very slight tendancy just occasionally to sound like their enclosures.
Equipment:
Source 16bit 44.1KHz FLAC files stored on computer.
DAC - Meridian Explorer
Cable - standard £2 3.5mm jack to phono RCA.
A smooth DAC and a not-pacey pair of BT3. I think I prefer faster audio kit, but anyway.... this is what I think.
Impressions No offensive buzzing when there is no music playing.
Even after being allowed to burn-in over for four days, they still seemed to have been softening in sound. Initially they were cold sounding and had a very small sound stage; both aspects of which changed. I absolutely hear my Meridian Explorer signature in them. I hear the same sort of slight congestion when the going gets tough.
In every way though my Grado SR225e seemed to be faster and more detailed. These headphones could comfortably pause and take a breath while the BT3 are doing their best. That doesn't mean that the SR225e had it all their own way though. The BT3 get close to the SR225e sometimes. Also because of the new presentation I hear details I missed in my headphones. The details are there in the headphones, but overlooked because other sounds are more forward.
An area where the 225e were winning was in bass response. Given the Grado Prestige Series are reputed as not bass heavy, this isn't good. This may be the fault of my cheap 3.5mm jack to RCA though. I can't confirm this until I buy a quality cable. However doing a little equalising and the BT3 make more sense. My music player allows me to EQ at 31HZ and 62Hz at the lower end. 31Hz had zero effect, meaning the BT3 have zero response at that frequency. However increasing just 3dB at 62Hz and the BT3 had a new lease of life. The lower sounds were all warmer and the overall signature seems normal.
I have settled with increasing 3dB at 50Hz in the Windows Control Panel thus eq-ing all sound from my PC. I had not forseen this bass lightness and to be honest the bass is quite weak without EQ. If this is the natural performance and not cable related, adding a source without EQ would be affected. For music at near field, close up the music sounds good. They do fit the the function of desktop speakers. It took a while to adjust to them though.
Techno sounds surpisingly a little warm and pristine. Testing with Bellisima (DJ Quicksilver) and Seven Days One week (B.B.E.). There's a solidity and punch. Fading Like a Flower (Dancing DJs vs Roxette) fills your ears and messes with air pressure, which is good!
Abba Gold sounded a little digital and harsh sounding on my headphones. Sounds fairly normal on BT3. The best of Lang Lang pretty good representation. However lacking some bite.
The Best of Sade - Smooth jazz, which needs more clarity in the purcussive taps.
Hawkwind - Brainstorm (from Doremi Fasol Latido album) sounded much as I hoped. It was a little slow in timing and could have used more clarity but the album conveyed well.
PC Gaming For this use they are good speakers. Initially I much preferred my headhones. However after a couple of days burning-in I moved to the BT3 most of the time. I found it a more relaxing way to hear audio in games. They produce an audio experience which fills all available space in front so allowing for immersion. Only when absolute directional information of enemy placement is necessary will the headphones be better. I played through Crysis 3 and the BT3 were totally on form. The only thing I missed was rain sounds coming from behind which headphones do. However good interconnect does help with that, so I need to get one.
Watching DVD Again they do really well for this job. Watching content is easier with speakers that with headphones. It's because I am not constantly aware movement is restricted and I can relax more. Sound is immersive and takes you closer to the movie.
Upgrades. A quality 3.5mm jack to RCA (Hopefully this would fill out the bass, and increase speed and detail.) All reviews of five-star cables claim better detail so I am going to buy one. A quality length of speaker cable between the master and slave speaker should also make a good upgrade.
Final Impressions. I think the better deal was the Onkyo A9010 and the Q Acoustics 3020 currently on Richer Sounds at £315. It would have been my choice if two aspects had not changed my mind. I have no space for the amplifier. The 3020 are best 15cm from a rear wall and that moves the speakers forward. They would have been too close to the user on desktop.
I expected more from the BT3. However I think I can not expect too much given the weak interconnect between DAC and BT3. I know from experience that good quality cables make all the difference. A cable described as being fast and detailed would be ideal. Neither is the DAC really of exceptional quality. Having said this the BT3 are good speakers. The ground work is done, meaning with the weak cable, they are a reasonable package.
If a new 3.5mm to RCA cable adds the missing bass, then they will be great. However if not then the BT3 for me do not operate without EQ. They are too bass light and not a complete package.
At the moment they also have a very slight tendancy just occasionally to sound like their enclosures.