Clare Newsome:
Which is why we've featured digital media products, active speakers, streaming, MP3, DACs etc in WHF for 10+ years - including Awards for the Airport Express when it first came out, ditto Sonos, Apple TV, iPod etc etc etc etc...
More than happy to debate and discuss all these issues, plus feedback on our coverage and suggestions for further features/sections etc.
Sorry Clare - please don't think I was criticising you or the magazine. It was more a general comment that with all the problems AJ and co. cause with their special brand of acidic evangelism, it is all too easy for their very valid message to get drowned in circular arguments.
I'm not talking about the anti-subjectivist stance either. As a musician I believe music itself is a very subjective thing, so it stands to reason that hi-fi is going to be as well. I don't subscribe to the notion that everyone should force themselves to like the same sound. Indeed, the 'listen with your own ears' approach is one of the things that has kept me interested in WHFS&V over the years.
I just believe that there is clearly something in the product, and something in the computer based approach, that merits a clarity of discussion that AVI make very hard. It clouds things particularly negatively when you read the forums mentioned earlier and see no punches pulled in slagging off people like yourself, Andrew, and Dave from Frank Harvey for whom I have the utmost respect based on what I've read on these forums.