A new turntable, compatible with the new HD vinyl technology is recommended, but not essential, is the claim which presumably means you'll be able to play HD records on existing turntables; however, to get the full benefit you'll need to buy an HD compatible turntable. I think it's obvious where this is going, not that it seems it will be going anywhere for three years according to the company involved; they've just applied for patents. So you want to try a new HD vinyl disc and it sounds pretty good on your expensive old record player, but there'll always be that nagging and neurotic audiophile voice: 'Better buy an HD turntable...it must sound brilliant on a dedicated turntable'. Well, it should do! Then, of course, there'll be a massive reissue programme of all your favourites which will be a shot in the arm for an ailing music industry. Who won't be tempted to hear 'The Wurzel's Greatest Hit' lp in high definition? On the other hand, it may be aimed at a niche market with a few 'quality' releases.
What it won't be is AAA technology; obviously, there'll be some digital in the chain, which, of course as members have pointed out, is already widespread and digital masters are used when repressing back catalogue material like 'The Beatles in Mono' lps. Does it matter if it sounds good? That's up to the individual and what they want for the money they spend/invest. For music recorded in 'the digital age' then it won't make much difference because the digital process was, er, obviously used; it should just have more clarity and definition...well, you'd hope so if you're spending loads of money on it.
What's my beef then? Well, I thought records sound great because of analogue technology. Isn't that what we like about them? That euphonic warmth? Yeah, I know...that inaccurate euphonic warmth. Will the new HD vinyl sound so clearly-defined and accurate in terms of presentation that that vibration -induced warmth is lost? Will there no longer be 'a vinyl sound'? Is it important? Does anybody really care?
It doesn't matter to me anyway to be honest; I'll still hunt for first pressings with AAA integrity becuse I'm of a certain age, but that doesn't mean I won't look forward to hearing 'Rubber Soul' or 'Kid A' in the new format. I'm just worried about how it might tempt me to re-mortgage my house and spend thousands of pounds that I'd ike to leave to my children. They're worried too.