Creek - what happened to...

[DIB]

HiFi News June issue reviews the Creek 50, anyone got hold of it?

Only read the excellent HiFi Choice review. I'm still interested to know when the 50D CD/DAC./Pre-Amp will see the light of day.

.

 

[MusicalRabbit]

When first announced the new cd player and amp were £500 approx each, making a combo around £1000 - £1100.

The above review now suggest they are £700 each, which makes a combo now £1400.

£400 above inital target price is quite a steep hike in approximation and as such has knocked me out of the ball park for this anticipated couple.

A shame.

 

[BigH]

When first announced the new cd player and amp were £500 approx each, making a combo around £1000 - £1100.

The above review now suggest they are £700 each, which makes a combo now £1400.

£400 above inital target price is quite a steep hike in approximation and as such has knocked me out of the ball park for this anticipated couple.

A shame.

Maybe that was ex. VAT? Some dealers will give you a discount, or ex-demo should be £100 or so less.

 

[BigH]

I did see the review briefly, also if you look on the Creek website I think there is a copy. Maybe WHF will review it?

 

[MusicalRabbit]

If the cd player comes out later this year, I'd seriously consider a combo of this Creek gear, especially if I could get the price down to nearer what was stated at the start of all this. Prices should be clearly indicated as ex VAT to avoid confusion for the buying public.

And yes, WhatHiFi should review also.

 

[sortof]

I just read the review in the latest audio (04/2013) edition which is a very good magazine. The 50A got a good, but not a great review. If you read the review you can read that in many ways they preferred the old Evolution 2 amplifier.

Well, they praise the 50A for its speed and transparency but criticize it as bass shy. While I don´t think "Audio" is a very good magazine this observation is not too far off the Choice review in which in absolute terms a lack of some bass heft was noted.

 

[NHL]

The Creek got 85% in the HiFi News group test. More than Primare and Arcam´s new amp. "Outstanding dynamics". The grade is rather high, especially considering its price.

By the way, have anyone got a listen yet?

 

[NHL]

Considering it might be bass shy, as Audio.de suggest,

wouldn't PMC transmission line speakers be the ideal speaker?

 

[Cypher]

Considering it might be bass shy, as Audio.de suggest,

wouldn't PMC transmission line speakers be the ideal speaker?

I don't know but the amp shouldn't be bass shy in the first place. After reading the reviews of the amp I'm not that interested any more.

 

[DIB]

I've not heard a 50A but if its anything like the Evo 2 or 5350 models then I would not describe it as bass shy. Quality bass more like.

.

 

[Cypher]

A review in What Hifi should be nice

 

[NHL]

A review in What Hifi should be nice

What HiFi is not as rose tinted as the other two magazines might be, which is why we´re nagging for a third opinion. :wave:

 

[paulsue38]

I have read the review. The Creek won the test and it was described as the best mid range amp currently available. The Arcam A19 also did very well in the test
Paul

 

[Ajani]

A review in What Hifi should be nice

What HiFi is not as rose tinted as the other two magazines might be, which is why we´re nagging for a third opinion. :wave:

I'm not so sure about the "rose tinted" part, but WHF tends to have different opinions from other mags. So it would be interesting to see another opinion. Though based on the HFC and HFN reviews I think it's fair to say that the Creek is a must audition in its price range.

 

[NHL]

The May issue supertest with 7 amps missed to include the creek.

 

[mikegtar]

Yes, I noticed the Creek is missing too... maybe WHF are waiting for the Pre amp/CD/DAC and test them together and use the amp just as a power amp. They say that makes it sound even better.

 

[BigH]

It would be good to have a group test with amps around £700, inc. Audiolab, Cyrus, Creek, Arcam, Naim, RK. etc.

 

[Andrew Everard]

There's just such a test in the May issue, on sale today

/sites/whathifi.com/files/images/newsarchive5/amplifier_supertest_0.jpg

Runners and riders:
Arcam FMJ A19
Audiolab 8200A
Cyrus 6a
Naim Nait 5i
Onix A-25
Pioneer A-70
Rotel RA-12

 

[BigH]

Why no Creek, seems to be plenty of interest in it?

 

[chebby]

Why no Creek, seems to be plenty of interest in it?

If Creek don't submit a sample for review, then ... no review.

 

[NHL]

Why no Creek, seems to be plenty of interest in it?

If Creek don't submit a sample for review, then ... no review.

Fine, then the issue is sorted out. Will stop commenting about the missing Creek.

 

[nopiano]

Why no Creek, seems to be plenty of interest in it?

If Creek don't submit a sample for review, then ... no review.

I think if I were a manufacturer with two top write ups from magazines, which I could quote in publicity, I might not risk a less enthusiastic one which would spoil the overall impression.

Creek clearly make good products which many people like. And if fans are curious there are plenty of dealers to listen at.

 

[BigH]

Why no Creek, seems to be plenty of interest in it?

If Creek don't submit a sample for review, then ... no review.

I think if I were a manufacturer with two top write ups from magazines, which I could quote in publicity, I might not risk a less enthusiastic one which would spoil the overall impression.

Creek clearly make good products which many people like. And if fans are curious there are plenty of dealers to listen at.

Why not buy one, Im sure WHF can afford to buy it, Im sure they would get their money back from increased sales, then sell it on, probably only cost £100.

Actually there are no Creek dealers in my county.

 

[NHL]

Why no Creek, seems to be plenty of interest in it?

If Creek don't submit a sample for review, then ... no review.

I think if I were a manufacturer with two top write ups from magazines, which I could quote in publicity, I might not risk a less enthusiastic one which would spoil the overall impression.

Creek clearly make good products which many people like. And if fans are curious there are plenty of dealers to listen at.

Let me add that I've saved a lot of money by studying WHF reviews!

 

[floyd droid]

What HiFi is not as rose tinted as the other two magazines might be, which is why we´re nagging for a third opinion. :wave:

:roll:

Lol, love it. Ken Kessler giving a rose tinted review, yeah right. If tis c**p he dosnt mess around. Neither does Bamford/Keywood etc etc.