• Thanks to each and every one of you for being part of the What Hi-fi? community! We hope you have a joyous holiday season!

Have I made mistake with Arcam 10 + 10p!!! Is it amps or speakers......can anyone save me and give me music to my ears please?!

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the What HiFi community: the world's leading independent guide to buying and owning hi-fi and home entertainment products.

drummerman

New member
Jan 18, 2008
540
5
0
Visit site
I think this has happened to most of us at some stage ... visit a cafe or a friend, they have a cheap system, maybe even some sony micro or whatever and it sounds musical and nice ... ****** when it happens :)

regards
 

davedotco

New member
Apr 24, 2013
20
1
0
Visit site
Overdose said:
Firstly, unless there is a fundamental problem with one of your amplifiers, changing them is unlikely to make the large difference that you appear to need.

Forget modding.

As suggested, check all wiring connections and double check, as something simple could well be the issue.

Failing all that, the integrated amp is plenty powerful enough for most hifi speakers, so you might be best to offload the speakers and power amp and then go on the hunt for a pair of speakers that you like.

Edit: I see that you have checked the wiring. Why not get the same system as your friends if it has the sound you are looking for?

If you are determined to simply swap boxes in the hope of getting something you like, this is reasonable advice.

The reality is that you have somehow managed to aquire one of the least involving, least engaging systems produced in the nineties, the Arcam amps are smooth and refined, determined not to offend, for largish speakers the Chesters have little in the way of bass weight or punch and a lack of presence throughout out the rest of the range.

Though that might suit some people it is about as much use playing the kind of rock music that you seem to favour as it is possible to get for the money, it is really no surprise you don't like the results.

There are plenty of people on here that will recommend that you buy all the usual suspects, a Marantz this, Monitor Audio that and all the other mid fi components that are currently flavour of the month.

Dare to be different, go to a dealer and try something that plays your style of music in an engaging way that lifts your spirits, don't worry if it does not conform to conventional wisdom, if it does not contain 5* products that are flavour of the month, buy something that engages you!
 

CnoEvil

New member
Aug 21, 2009
556
14
0
Visit site
davedotco said:
Dare to be different, go to a dealer and try something that plays your style of music in an engaging way that lifts your spirits, don't worry if it does not conform to conventional wisdom, if it does not contain 5* products that are flavour of the month, buy something that engages you!

Totally agree.

IMO. This is the key to success....where success is the enjoyment of music, rather than the acquiring of stars.
 

chebby

Well-known member
Jun 2, 2008
1,257
34
19,220
Visit site
CnoEvil said:
davedotco said:
Dare to be different, go to a dealer and try something that plays your style of music in an engaging way that lifts your spirits, don't worry if it does not conform to conventional wisdom, if it does not contain 5* products that are flavour of the month, buy something that engages you!

Totally agree.

IMO. This is the key to success....where success is the enjoyment of music, rather than the acquiring of stars.

Good luck with that. Most hi-fi shops don't exactly 'dare to be different' either. (I am trying to stop using the word 'dealer' in favour of 'shop'. I don't buy beef from a 'meat dealer'.)
 

CnoEvil

New member
Aug 21, 2009
556
14
0
Visit site
chebby said:
Good luck with that. Most hi-fi shops don't exactly 'dare to be different' either. (I am trying to stop using the word 'dealer' in favour of 'shop'. I don't buy beef from a 'meat dealer'.)

They do exist though..........
 
T

the record spot

Guest
Rather than just jump in to a dealer, first have a think about what kind of sounds you like, then read up on what's on the market today. Bear in mind however that some think that a lot of today's gear apparently has a brighter sound to it.

Were it my money, I'd keep the Arcam amps for now. You can always sell them later. The 10 was well rated in its day and it won't be rubbish overnight now. There's ample power on offer, so I'll suggest you try and find a pair of Mission 751s. This is a standmount model but could work very well with your amps. I used mine with an Alpha 5 amp and they rocked. The bass is not wanting from these, but that depends on how much bass you're after I guess. It might be worth seeking a pair out. They come up frequently and a mint set will be around £100-150. You'll need stands too but they're £60 or so, or less if you buy used. Could be a good pairing with the 10s and they're as good as anything up to £500 on the market just now.

Do have a think about what you really want though as I doubt walking into a dealer's without doing some of your own legwork beforehand is any guarantee of success.
 

steve_1979

Well-known member
Jul 14, 2010
231
10
18,795
Visit site
matthewpiano said:
davedotco said:
Sell what you have for as much as you can get.

Visit a competent dealer and listen to some systems.

Buy the one you like.

Do not rely on others to choose a system for you.

I'm quoting this to bring it back to the OP's attention. Its good advice.

+1

I have to agree. This seems like very sensible advice to me.
 
T

the record spot

Guest
CnoEvil said:
chebby said:
Good luck with that. Most hi-fi shops don't exactly 'dare to be different' either. (I am trying to stop using the word 'dealer' in favour of 'shop'. I don't buy beef from a 'meat dealer'.)

They do exist though..........

Look long and hard. Most dealers sell the usual suspects, the ones that don't come with the ticket price to match and while they have their place, are we surprised that an ex-dealer is going to advocate just walking in and buying after a couple of hours demo with what's in the shop? You'll need a bit more than that I think if you want to avoid the usual suspects Dave mentions.

Dealers I'd be looking at would be the like of Emporium HiFi or Big Ears Audio. High street ones I wouldn't go near without a shortlist of speakers to hand first. Chebby was on the money here.
 

CnoEvil

New member
Aug 21, 2009
556
14
0
Visit site
the record spot said:
Look long and hard. Most dealers sell the usual suspects, the ones that don't come with the ticket price to match and while they have their place, are we surprised that an ex-dealer is going to advocate just walking in and buying after a couple of hours demo with what's in the shop? You'll need a bit more than that I think if you want to avoid the usual suspects Dave mentions.

Dealers I'd be looking at would be the like of Emporium HiFi or Big Ears Audio. High street ones I wouldn't go near without a shortlist of speakers to hand first. Chebby was on the money here.

You won't get an argument from me.......if it's worth doing well, it's worth putting the time and effort in.
 
T

the record spot

Guest
Not looking for one Cno, I just question the logic really. Baby and bathwater and all that.
 

amcluesent

New member
Mar 8, 2009
25
0
0
Visit site
Arcam 'house' sound can be snooze-making when partnered with middle-of-the-road speakers (been there with Arcam/B&W :doh:)

If you want bass and punch, have a listen to active speakers.
 

phydeau

New member
Jun 8, 2013
2
0
0
Visit site
Fairly new to all this, but here goes my two pence worth..

I have a Arcam 10, with Kef R100's. Unless there is a fault with your amp, I very much doubt it is the problem, as it produces the most gorgeous sound - deep, rich, crisp, detailed, 'juicy' - I sit listening for hours just captivated by how great it sounds. The bass on the R100's is surprisingly good given the size of speaker.

Then I stumbled across a secondhand pair of Roksan TR5's at a price that I'd easily get if I re-sold them, so I though 'why not'? So I'm experimenting with them, and I think I like them even more. A bit more 'get up and go' about them somehow, more forward, energetic. Big smile.

So I find the A 10 is fine by itself - they sell for good money - c£300, so are in demand still. I have found dealers to be very variable in helpfulness, especially at my budget end of the market, and also tend to have limited range. So my advice would be to cash in the power amp, which also go for good money, and go for a speaker change. I am enjoying the 'buy it second hand for what you can sell it for' route, as it allows for extended time to try things out.

Hope this helps.
 
T

the record spot

Guest
amcluesent said:
Arcam 'house' sound can be snooze-making when partnered with middle-of-the-road speakers (been there with Arcam/B&W :doh:)

If you want bass and punch, have a listen to active speakers.

...as but one option, but not exclusively so. And there are other considerations there too in any case.
 

CnoEvil

New member
Aug 21, 2009
556
14
0
Visit site
the record spot said:
Not looking for one Cno, I just question the logic really. Baby and bathwater and all that.

The joy of this forum is the eclectic mix of knowledge....whether you want vintage, valves, analogue or digital, active or passive. There are plenty of people recommending good "well known" brands, so I like to point to some of the lesser known alternatives....if nothing else, it gets them talked about.

As far as I'm concerned, there is no baby or bathwater, only the broadening of horizons which may allow better decisions to be made. :grin:
 

Pete68

New member
Nov 15, 2012
22
0
0
Visit site
I wouldn't rule out modifying the Alpha 10. The transformation was a huge surprise to me.

However...the Alpha 10 is no slouch and partnered with good kit should give you everything you need out of an amp at that price point. Anyway, I stand by what I have already said; modififying it will dramatically improve it's sonic performance.
 

69biscuit

New member
Feb 26, 2013
2
0
0
Visit site
Firstly, thank you to all of you who have taken the time to post replies on here, it really is much appreciated. There are obviously some conflicting opinions, which is to be expected through peoples own experiences, but good to read and take on board.

Selling the amps is very much a last result, this is not something I want to do, but yes they do have a good residual price, so not the end of the world if it does come to that. My preference would be to find some floor standing speakers that are extremely well complemented by the amp, this has been the problem. Amps are very bright as some of you have said, but I'm not completely defeated yet!

I have done a lot of research online to current components and potential ones, but there is no subtitute for actual listening, this is a problem if purchasing secondhand. For the time being due to cash flow, I think this would be my only solution, which I why I mentioned Monitor Audio's GR20, RS6, RX6 as they are reportedly quite bassy. Also in consideration was B&W 603 for the same reasons.

Anyway, this morning I have got in contact with Soundcraft in Ashford, Kent (where I live) and they have been really obliging. Have appointment booked next Saturday am and he is bringing Rel T5 and some B&W's, so we can try each component seperately and together, once helping to set it all up he's then offered to leave with me for a proper demo. I'd say that's service you can't beat, Sevenoaks wanted me to pay for items so I could demo and full credit on return....not bad but to me Soundcraft have just excelled from the off with this. I could be heavily in debt after there visit if I'm not careful though!

Furthermore, have spoken with friend who has the Tannoy F4 customs and he's going to bring those over at some point, so will be interesting to see how they sound in my room with Arcam 10's. I had the DC6T's on for the entire evening last night and I have to say they sounded a lot better by the end of the evening, I realise speakers have to be run in, so maybe that's partly the reason, it could of course always have something to do with the red wine I'd drunk too! :)

I will report findings next week.
 

Pete68

New member
Nov 15, 2012
22
0
0
Visit site
That sounds like a plan.

There really is no substitute for listening and the recommendations here are simply just advice from experience (or not).

Good luck with the quest for better SQ. You have good amps, you just need to find the right equipment synergy.
 

eggontoast

Well-known member
Feb 23, 2011
453
12
18,895
Visit site
Pete68 said:
I wouldn't rule out modifying the Alpha 10. The transformation was a huge surprise to me.

However...the Alpha 10 is no slouch and partnered with good kit should give you everything you need out of an amp at that price point. Anyway, I stand by what I have already said; modififying it will dramatically improve it's sonic performance.

Some sweeping statements here, there are no parallels between the Alpha 9 which you have and the Alpha 10, they are completely different animals. Besides modifying is going to be extremely subjective to say the least.

To the OP, the Alpha 10's are fine amplifiers and I would be extremely surprised if they were your problem, having said that they are getting on now and are beginning to suffer with dried out caps, there is also another little common fault which causes havoc with the auto bias circuit. So it might be an idea to get them serviced at some point just to make sure they are performing at their best.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
davedotco said:
Overdose said:
Firstly, unless there is a fundamental problem with one of your amplifiers, changing them is unlikely to make the large difference that you appear to need.

Forget modding.

As suggested, check all wiring connections and double check, as something simple could well be the issue.

Failing all that, the integrated amp is plenty powerful enough for most hifi speakers, so you might be best to offload the speakers and power amp and then go on the hunt for a pair of speakers that you like.

Edit: I see that you have checked the wiring. Why not get the same system as your friends if it has the sound you are looking for?

If you are determined to simply swap boxes in the hope of getting something you like, this is reasonable advice.

The reality is that you have somehow managed to aquire one of the least involving, least engaging systems produced in the nineties, the Arcam amps are smooth and refined, determined not to offend, for largish speakers the Chesters have little in the way of bass weight or punch and a lack of presence throughout out the rest of the range.

Though that might suit some people it is about as much use playing the kind of rock music that you seem to favour as it is possible to get for the money, it is really no surprise you don't like the results.

There are plenty of people on here that will recommend that you buy all the usual suspects, a Marantz this, Monitor Audio that and all the other mid fi components that are currently flavour of the month.

Dare to be different, go to a dealer and try something that plays your style of music in an engaging way that lifts your spirits, don't worry if it does not conform to conventional wisdom, if it does not contain 5* products that are flavour of the month, buy something that engages you!

+1 good advice
 

davedotco

New member
Apr 24, 2013
20
1
0
Visit site
Pete68 said:
That sounds like a plan.

There really is no substitute for listening and the recommendations here are simply just advice from experience (or not).

Good luck with the quest for better SQ. You have good amps, you just need to find the right equipment synergy.

Quite right.

What someone in the OP's position really needs is practical hands on experience, doing your research on line is just another way of getting someone else to chose your system for you.

Yes I know mainstream dealers sell mainstream product and I know that most of it is, well, mediocre, but the more experience you get the better you wil be able to sort the good from the not so good. If you really find that difficult for one reason or another and feel you have to rely on the recommendations of others, here are a couple of off the wall suggestions.

Given your musical tastes and your comments about your system lacking punch and presence, I would sell the power amp and speakers and see if Richer have still got any of the JBL Studio 580s they had a few weeks ago. Nothing whatsoever to do with 'classic' hi-fi but it will give Axl and Slash plenty of room to do their thing.

If a little more cash is available look at a pair of Mackie HR 824 at about £1k a pair. Massively capable near field monitors monitors with powerful deep bass, for an idea of what they can do, look up the comments on the Event Opal monitors on this site, the HR 824s are about as close as you can get for around half the price.

Be aware though, these options are not the nice girl next door with whom you are going to spend the rest of your life, this is the girl at the bar with the short skirt and a little too much makeup who is ready to show you how to really rock and roll.
 

CnoEvil

New member
Aug 21, 2009
556
14
0
Visit site
davedotco said:
Be aware though, these options are not the nice girl next door with whom you are going to spend the rest of your life, this is the girl at the bar with the short skirt and a little too much makeup who is ready to show you how to really rock and roll.

I know which I'd go for.......but I've got a very dodgy back! :shifty:
 

davedotco

New member
Apr 24, 2013
20
1
0
Visit site
CnoEvil said:
davedotco said:
Be aware though, these options are not the nice girl next door with whom you are going to spend the rest of your life, this is the girl at the bar with the short skirt and a little too much makeup who is ready to show you how to really rock and roll.

I know which I'd go for.......but I've got a very dodgy back! :shifty:

Is that from moving around that bl**dy amplifier of yours or from doing something rather more interesting?
 

TRENDING THREADS

Latest posts