CD players - Are they a dieing breed?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the What HiFi community: the world's leading independent guide to buying and owning hi-fi and home entertainment products.

byakuya83

New member
Mar 14, 2011
63
1
0
Visit site
The_Lhc said:
charles_mo said:
I would not upgrade my CD player because I cannot justify the cost for something I think I will not use that much. But the network player will mean I will not have a CD player when I want to listen purely to the music in the best possible light.

What network player is it? There's no good reason why you couldn't get the same level of quality as you get from the CD player. Of course you might need to spend some money to do it but presumably you spent some money on the CD player in the first place, so it's only fair if you want to make a proper comparison.

There's nothing inherently "worse" about streaming, compared to CD, if you do it right.

Just for the record, I've never owned a CD player (apart from the ones in my cars).

I tend to agree that streaming and palying a CD should result in the same output.

Does the same apply with regard to wireless streaming?

There are a great many reviews on this website that suggest it doesn't...quite why I do not know.

Perhaps someone can explain.
 

MajorFubar

New member
Mar 3, 2010
690
7
0
Visit site
Blackdawn said:
am happy spending my money on CD's until a better physical format appears.

Hope you're not hanging off a cliff by your fingernails waiting for that to happen, because it won't. Not in a 'mass market' way anyhow. SACD and DVD Audio have tried. But definitely at the moment CDs remain the best VFM way of buying most music in a quality digital format. :rockout:
 

Pete68

New member
Nov 15, 2012
22
0
0
Visit site
I like CD's but streaming digital music seems a lot more conveniant and with modern DACs the SQ is good enough for most people.

The real gains in SQ are to be had with vinyl and I am glad it's resurging. We lost a lot when CD came in, namely analogue. So I think streaming as the new digital source is good but vinyl/analogue is another great option once more.
 

eclecticmonkey

New member
Jul 20, 2011
12
0
0
Visit site
I just find that incredibly sad! As someone who eats, sleeps and breathes music I can't understand why anyone would want to listen to lower quality sound, sure I get the convenience thing and I love the fact that I can get my entire library on an iPod, and that's ok for holidays, listening on the bus, in the office etc but nothing beats listening to something of decent quality on a decent system. I'm just repeating an experiment I did a little while ago, comparing a few albums ripped at 320 Kbps with wavs on my iPod with both the standard iPod earphones and a pair of Sennheiser headphones. The first minute of PSB West End Girls tells me everything I need to know, an mp3 rip definitely has a detrimental effect on the audible elements of a piece despite claims to the contrary.
 

Covenanter

Well-known member
Jul 20, 2012
88
34
18,570
Visit site
Blackdawn said:
The use of CDs and CD players is definitely decreasing especially with the younger generations who have grown up with MP3s. Personally, I still like to own my music in a physical format so the CD is still bettter and more useful for me. I think CD players will be around for a while yet and am happy spending my money on CD's until a better physical format appears.

I'm with you but then I'm an old fogey.

Chris
 

Leeps

New member
Dec 10, 2012
219
1
0
Visit site
Derildo, a good point well-made.

For the last 26 years I've invested heavily in CD's and have seen many new 'wonder-formats' come and go. I've been considering dipping a toe into streaming / ripping etc, but so far a few reasons hold me back;

Look at this very forum under the streaming music section and you'll find an endless list of computer glitches, format issues, network problems and disappointed users who've spent lots of their hard-earned on a system that doesn't work anywhere near as reliably as their conventional system. I get computer problems all day at work, that's the last thing I want to think about when I choose to listen to music; I want it to work first time every time, and my CD player hasn't put a foot wrong in 9 Years. (Cue major CD player breakdown tomorrow!!). I don't have to concern myself over backups, keeping my NAS quieter than my music and tagging errors.

But also, while the likes of Linn and Naim are pushing streaming certain formats now, it only takes the likes of Apple/Universal/Sony to push their new HD format and to gain mainstream acceptance to make any new streaming equipment potentially obsolete. Do you think the big boys will care if they upset the customers of small volume British hifi manufacturers?

As the move from film to digital cameras showed, when formats that happily existed largely unaltered for decades jumped onto the digital bandwagon, the life expectancy and 2nd hand value of these new technologies plummeted dramatically.

I bought my first CD 26 years ago. In 26 years will we still be talking about 24/192 FLACS? Or sadly will we still be talking about 320kbps streaming? Who knows.

The market still appears to be in the Betamax/VHS/Laserdisc phase just now, and I know I'm cautious, but until the market comes up with something genuinely superior to CD and crucially gains mainstream acceptance, I'll stick with the beautiful simplicity of the CD format.

on, open, close, play....aaaaaah.
 

matt49

Well-known member
Apr 7, 2013
51
1
18,540
Visit site
Covenanter said:
Blackdawn said:
The use of CDs and CD players is definitely decreasing especially with the younger generations who have grown up with MP3s. Personally, I still like to own my music in a physical format so the CD is still bettter and more useful for me. I think CD players will be around for a while yet and am happy spending my money on CD's until a better physical format appears.

I'm with you but then I'm an old fogey.

Chris

Just a couple of points from personal experience.

Although my two teenage daughters normally buy their music from the iTunes store, they both have portable CD players in their bedrooms and are evidently keen on the medium. If one of my CDs has gone missing, I know where to look for it.

Also I'm a bit worried about their nonchalant attitude to data storage. I've been using PCs for 25 years now, and the need for multiple back-ups is scorched in my brain. My kids, despite supposedly learning about IT at school for several years (though that's another lamentable story of missed opportunities) and despite my repeated warnings, have made no attempts to back up any of their music files. One day soon that laptop is gonna go belly up, and then where will all your Taylor Swift be?

I stream my music from a NAS, and I say long live the physical medium of the CD!
 

daveh75

Well-known member
matt49 said:
Also I'm a bit worried about their nonchalant attitude to data storage. I've been using PCs for 25 years now, and the need for multiple back-ups is scorched in my brain. My kids, despite supposedly learning about IT at school for several years (though that's another lamentable story of missed opportunities) and despite my repeated warnings, have made no attempts to back up any of their music files. One day soon that laptop is gonna go belly up, and then where will all your Taylor Swift be?

I stream my music from a NAS, and I say long live the physical medium of the CD!

In the cloud...
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
daveh75 said:
matt49 said:
Also I'm a bit worried about their nonchalant attitude to data storage. I've been using PCs for 25 years now, and the need for multiple back-ups is scorched in my brain. My kids, despite supposedly learning about IT at school for several years (though that's another lamentable story of missed opportunities) and despite my repeated warnings, have made no attempts to back up any of their music files. One day soon that laptop is gonna go belly up, and then where will all your Taylor Swift be?

I stream my music from a NAS, and I say long live the physical medium of the CD!

In the cloud...

And what happens when the cloud servers die or get hacked or............

There is always something physical holding the data ;)
 

andyjm

New member
Jul 20, 2012
15
3
0
Visit site
Blackdawn said:
The use of CDs and CD players is definitely decreasing especially with the younger generations who have grown up with MP3s. Personally, I still like to own my music in a physical format so the CD is still bettter and more useful for me. I think CD players will be around for a while yet and am happy spending my money on CD's until a better physical format appears.

I have 3 sons between 19 and 13. None have ever owned a CD, nor do they show any sign of doing so.

I think it is very unlikely that a 'better physical format' will appear. Its day has gone. I am not aware of any manufacturers proposing to develop a replacement CD after the failure of DVD A and SACD.
 

BigH

Well-known member
Dec 29, 2012
113
7
18,595
Visit site
CD will be around for a while yet, although I can see some labels not producing them for some artists, this is already happening and is good for new artists to launch music just by downloads. Going forward I see cd sales falling more and more demand for high res. downloads. Some downloads you can print off the sleeve etc or just have it on your screen. I buy a few cds mostly used ones for about £1.30 and few new ones for £5, but mostly listen to music on Spotify or Rdio. Itunes are supposed to be launching some hi-res music, not sure if its happening yet as I never use iTunes.

The latest thing is DSD or DXD but very few albums are recorded in this format mainly due to cost I believe and it is mainly classical.
 

TitusG

New member
Oct 12, 2008
61
0
0
Visit site
Are there any independant hifi repairers in you area? My cd6 died and my hifi dealer recommended an independant that should hopefully be much cheaper than Cyrus.
 

GMK

New member
Jan 23, 2009
27
0
0
Visit site
andyjm said:
I have 3 sons between 19 and 13. None have ever owned a CD, nor do they show any sign of doing so.

I think it is very unlikely that a 'better physical format' will appear. Its day has gone. I am not aware of any manufacturers proposing to develop a replacement CD after the failure of DVD A and SACD.

I would be quite happy to have my music on a hard drive if a lossless alternative proved as good as CD. I tried downloading an album onto a flash drive into my Onkyo 8050 ("lossless" FLAC) and while it was very good quality, CD still sounded better. I was really disappointed. I would love to do away with the bulk of hundreds of CD's
 

BigH

Well-known member
Dec 29, 2012
113
7
18,595
Visit site
Gibs_MK said:
andyjm said:
I have 3 sons between 19 and 13. None have ever owned a CD, nor do they show any sign of doing so.

I think it is very unlikely that a 'better physical format' will appear. Its day has gone. I am not aware of any manufacturers proposing to develop a replacement CD after the failure of DVD A and SACD.

I would be quite happy to have my music on a hard drive if a lossless alternative proved as good as CD. I tried downloading an album onto a flash drive into my Onkyo 8050 ("lossless" FLAC) and while it was very good quality, CD still sounded better. I was really disappointed. I would love to do away with the bulk of hundreds of CD's

What software are you using on the Onkyo 8050 to play the FLAC?
 

charles_mo

New member
Sep 11, 2008
6
0
0
Visit site
Thank you for all your useful replies and they were all very informative indeed. However, I might say I have heard nothing really new to help me decide on what to do with my broken Cyrus CD 6, but it has got me thinking we are at a point of change for sure with Digital Music and CDs.

I refer to Digital Music because it is the term to refer to music downloads, and it is a trend we will not be able to stop. The more demand we make to have ever faster broadband and mobile broadband speeds Digital Music will develop, and the once high tech CD will be pushed to the side. I will be explaining to my kids one day for sure, that CDs where the old way of listening music, and remembering nostalgically the good old days of jammed CD trays.

Streaming music will get better in quality over time, because of faster broadband connections will allow almost lossless streaming. Remember SACD and the development of 24bit CDs, streaming HD Audio will come. But it will not be a format war, because it is not about backing one technology in this context, which means your equipment will become obsolete. Because it is all software and you all know our computers can pretty much play any file format. VHS and Betamax is not relevant any more these machines were of a generation before advanced software systems. They here mechanical and electronic, and did not upgrade itself if connected to the internet.

No instead it will be not about the format, but the promise of high quality music delivered to you in a rich interactive content format. iTunes has already done this as you browse through music art, albums, and artist with news and content, and you just need to hit a button and the music is available to you. It is not the bad old thing of instant gratification, but enjoyment of music is important and making it easier to obtain is not a bad thing. It is not solely about technology either, but the way technology enables you to have the enjoyment of music without the headaches what format to use, NAS, updates, WiFi, etc. Please have trust in the innovation of engineers who design and developed these products. They all want you to enjoy the use of their products, and the last thing they want is for it to fail on you. It is just that these wonderful consumer devices are getting easier to use, but they hide an immense complication from you that engineers have to manage. Imagine why people keep saying these days you pocket Smart Phone is in order of million times more processing power than the computers in the first Apollo mission. Infact, your USB flash disk itself has more power than Apollo 11 computers, and this is because the software it runs is actually more complex than the software running on the Apollo 11 to take you to space. That is the amazing fact, but what is more amazing is that we pick up our phones and we don't even blink at this amazing amount of computing power.

This year you will see a revolution that will deliver music across your internet connection that would put CDs on our history books forever. I am afraid this is true and it is progress no matter what the argument is. We all had that with Vinyl and when CDs came the same was said about CDs being inferior, and the album art was so much smaller and less collective than the Vinyl. John Lewis is even selling the Vinyl and their covers stored i npicture frames for you to hang on the wall, which you can unclip to play on your deck. Only problem John Lewis doesn't even sell a record deck of any quality to talk about.

Sorry but I am a believer in streaming, but I do agree at the moment it is a mess. Those manufacturers who have built network players/streamers don't get it. Their systems rely on poor technology i.e. PCs or NAS, which are prone to failure and the home network which is always prone to go offline. The Cloud is the way forward, because our broadband is as important to the electricity and gas supply these days.

Having physical CDs is really only a "comfort" factor people cling to them, but it is not the only way to deliver content in terms of art and written notes from the artist. No, delivery of music streamed is the only way artist can earn a living in the long term, because it is streamed from a sourced that is reputable who has signed a contract and is paying the artist. CD, files copies, are all prone to piracy. Also cloud is much safer to have your music stored. Companies spend millions to ensure the data is kept safe. No one ever complains about the trillions of pounds our pensions, personal money is stored. This is not stored physically, but electronically in huge computer databases. Like money notes, CDs are not timeless and degrade over time, get lost, scratch, damaged by heat when left in the car, and god hopes it never happens goes up in smoke unless you store it in a fire proof safe. I bet no one does this. However music in the cloud does not suffer from any of this, and will remain with you way after you have gone. In fact, all of us will leave a digital legacy of our life's on this planet in the cloud/internet, and that thingy midget we called FaceBook.

So the question is now back to my CD player. My faithful Cyrus CD 6 which decided to die on me. Well I have decided to give it a kiss of life. I will give it one more change, and send it back to Cyrus for repairs. All because I don't want to invest in anything because I have a perfectly good streaming solution from Apple, which I have on good authority will advance this year with something that will change the way we consume music. The Cyrus might therefore get a change to spin up those silver discs, which were so modern when I saw it for the first time on Tomorrows World played on a giant Philips CD player.

So guys I have been around myself and saw the first introduction of CDs. However, I always promised myself to be a Tomorrows man, and less of yesterdays.
 

Overdose

Well-known member
Feb 8, 2008
279
1
18,890
Visit site
charles_mo said:
The Cyrus might therefore get a change to spin up those silver discs, which were so modern when I saw it for the first time on Tomorrows World played on a giant Philips CD player.

So guys I have been around myself and saw the first introduction of CDs. However, I always promised myself to be a Tomorrows man, and less of yesterdays.

Was that the one where they dragged a few behind a car to show how indestructable they were and proceeded to play them after?

They forgot to factor in CD corrosion and I have actually had a couple of discs crack clean in two from a simple drop onto a carpeted floor. :doh:
 
andyjm said:
Blackdawn said:
The use of CDs and CD players is definitely decreasing especially with the younger generations who have grown up with MP3s. Personally, I still like to own my music in a physical format so the CD is still bettter and more useful for me. I think CD players will be around for a while yet and am happy spending my money on CD's until a better physical format appears.

I have 3 sons between 19 and 13. None have ever owned a CD, nor do they show any sign of doing so.

I think it is very unlikely that a 'better physical format' will appear. Its day has gone. I am not aware of any manufacturers proposing to develop a replacement CD after the failure of DVD A and SACD.

Try telling the Japanese that SACD's are a failure. :)
 

BigH

Well-known member
Dec 29, 2012
113
7
18,595
Visit site
Alears said:
Try telling the Japanese that SACD's are a failure. :)

They maybe more popular in Japan but I do think they are a failure, that is why they released many in hybrid format. Also there are still so few albums available and many have limited release numbers so to buy now cost over £100.
 

matt49

Well-known member
Apr 7, 2013
51
1
18,540
Visit site
charles_mo said:
Like money notes, CDs are not timeless and degrade over time, get lost, scratch, damaged by heat when left in the car, and god hopes it never happens goes up in smoke unless you store it in a fire proof safe.

No, obviously that would be silly, but it is standard omdustry practice in IT to keep a physical back-up pf all dogital data. i share your enthusiasm for streaming but as I noted on another thread physical back-up of data is essential. You say that companies spend millions on preserving so-called 'cloud' data. What those millions are actually spent on is physical data centres full of physical servers. Banks back up all their data physically in real time. I'm not suggesting you should do the same, but under no circumstances would I rely on the 'cloud' for back-up.
 
BigH said:
Alears said:
Try telling the Japanese that SACD's are a failure. :)

They maybe more popular in Japan but I do think they are a failure, that is why they released many in hybrid format. Also there are still so few albums available and many have limited release numbers so to buy now cost over £100.

There are actually quite a range and number of SACD's available, but granted, they can be a tad expensive. However I guess we are getting a little bit away from the OP's question.

CD players will still be utilised until every bit of new music produced is available as a high res download, I feel.
 

BigH

Well-known member
Dec 29, 2012
113
7
18,595
Visit site
Alears said:
BigH said:
Alears said:
Try telling the Japanese that SACD's are a failure. :)

They maybe more popular in Japan but I do think they are a failure, that is why they released many in hybrid format. Also there are still so few albums available and many have limited release numbers so to buy now cost over £100.

There are actually quite a range and number of SACD's available, but granted, they can be a tad expensive. However I guess we are getting a little bit away from the OP's question.

CD players will still be utilised until every bit of new music produced is available as a high res download, I feel.

Maybe there are a few available but of the ones that I would be interested in, there are either none ever made or not available or very expensive but some are available as high-res downloads from companies like HDTracks, for example Santana Abraxus is available on SACD for £117 I think is the cheapest Ive seen but you can get this from HDTracks for about $18. Don't think any Led Zepp albums are on SACD? The Doors you can get on both but downloads are cheaper. About the only SACD I would consider buying is Wish Your Were Here which is about £25.
 

john dolan

New member
Dec 20, 2008
3
0
0
Visit site

BigH

Well-known member
Dec 29, 2012
113
7
18,595
Visit site
john dolan said:
I got this today

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Modern-Cool-Blu-ray-Patricia-Barber/dp/B00802EYDO/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1365519183&sr=8-1&keywords=Patricia+Barber+blu-ray

192/24 blu-ray audio and it sounds great coax out into my M-dac.

Maybe blu-ray is the new cd.

Can buy a good blu-ray player for £100 or so and run it out to a dac if you wish and it will play cd dvd and blu-ray 3d and will have usb inputs for a hd full of tunes or movies and can stream from a NAS.

Well most BR players can play SACDs so they are very similar, so yes that is worth looking out for.

And I will be buying a BR player very soon, whether it is better than my Marantz cd players for RD cds I will hav eto try them out.

I prefer Patricia Barber's Cafe Blue but that is not on dvd and the sacd is £395, think I will stick to spotify.
 

cse

Well-known member
Mar 3, 2008
97
5
18,545
Visit site
For classical music CD and SACD is very much the present and the immediate future. Gramophone magazine's pages of new releases every month, are almost always in the above formats, as is BBC's weekly CD review - despite Andrew's unnecessary endless promotion of download/streaming in his audio column, most fans are happy with the medium. Sound quality is paramount in the classical world and not really affected by whether or not the new release is in CD or SACD format. I have many CD's which sound better than SACD's despite owning a Marantz Pearl Lite SACD player.
 

tounra

New member
Sep 25, 2007
7
0
0
Visit site
I agree with cse and as long as Spotify doesn't have a license with my favorite label Harmonia Mundi I am 'forced' to buy CDs anyway.

And there still is something special about having the actual physical product, especially when the music comes in such a handsome package, just leave it to Harmonia Mundi to add that extra luxurious feel.

And CD's are more affordable than ever, I order my CDs at Prestoclasical, a great site.
 

TRENDING THREADS

Latest posts