Vladimir said:
Thompsonuxb said:
Vladimir said:
The point about the coordinates and time paradoxes in the story is that it remains unclear and not quite obvious to the viewer. Later interpretations and analysis is pointless if those observations skipped during the actual movie watching.?
However, unlike Thompson, this didn't trouble me at all, I just glazed through any issues and enjoyed the movie. I'm not a sci-fi pedant. I almost cried when the aliens beeped back in Close Encounters Of The Third Kind.
Vlad, I love a good scfi - I like Alien3 - but the film just did not work for me on too many levels.
That's all.
Every sci-fi movie has script flaws, timeline issues, wonky technology of its time etc. However, you didn't say I think Interstellar is an OK or a good film, it just has issues. You said you'd rather get shot in the knee than stand to watch another minute of it. A bit excessive in your dismissall.?
BTW what are the Pros and Cons of Tesseract in your opinion?
My issues with the Tesseract - it's location on the edge of the event horizon - the 'gravity' in this region is powerful enough to theoretically crush planets, not even light can escape it - physics ignored?
But glaze over that and we still have Cooper a 3dimensional being existing in a 4 or 5 dimensional space he still has a physical
presents to move those books (across time) and why would the robot be saved?
Oh he did not send back the co-ordinates and at no point was there any suggestion he could manipulate the local magnetic field in his daughter's room to leave the co-ordinates in the dust to the secret NASA facility.
Wash over that...
The other point - his daughter had a strop for 20 odd years
were she would not message him - why did he not send a message to say he was ok.
And once in the Tesseract only one single timeline was available to Cooper, his
daughters.
Again time was a main play in this film how long was a second in the Tesseract - once it spat him out in 'safe space' he had not aged. Yet on the planet close to the black hole an hour cost them 20odd years.
Only 114yrs had passed when they found him - surely closer to the black hole more time would have passed and he was also spat out far away enough from the blackhole not to get sucked into it.
To many flaws makes the film hard to watch for me.