Ronald Archiebald:
Maxflinn,
So, the higher the resolution of the screen, the greater the degradation in quality with SD content?
This obviously works in the opposite with HD content, with Full HD supposedly able to deliver a superior picture quality?
Using your argument, SD content is then at it's best quality at it's native resolution , using a non-HD TV set?
As an example : a regular dvd player which outputs at 576p as opposed to using a dvd player with an upscaler that upscales the content to 720p/1080i - the upscaler would produce a better picture, without doubt.
So, using that same theory, a Full HD TV should perform better than a HD-Ready TV even with SD material too.
No?
Ronald
yes , standard definition , 576p , looks best on a good sd tv ..
full 1080p material looks better on a full hdtv ..
different components have different quality scalers ..
eg . if you spin a dvd on a denon 2500 bdp , and send it to a pioneer kuro lx 5090 unscaled , ie 576p .. the kuro will display a better upscaled picture than if it was receiving the data at 1080p , ie , if the denon was doing the scaling ..the kuros scaling is better than the denons , or any other dvdp , bdp , or tv ..
when a tv , dvdp , bdp , ps3 etc is upscaling , its basically trying to guess where the data goes on the high res screen , 576p to 1080p , is more challenging than 720p to 1080p .. 576p to 720p is less demanding of the scaler of tv , bdp whatever than 576p to 1080p , so sd often looks better on a 720p tv than a 1080p tv , but not always , the quality of components scaling abilities , tvs ability etc come into play ..
thats my best effort anyways