I Love You Honeybear by Father John Misty is another one. Caught me out the first time, especially as I wasn't familiar with Father John Misty at the time and bought it as per my wife's request. Put it on and thought, damn...this is slow...doesn't sound right! So I asked my wife if this it's supposed to sound that way (since I don't know it), and she's like "yeah, it's supposed to sound that way". So we listened the next track with a massive frown, and by the 3rd track I just picked up the arm, said it's not right and sounds sh*t, switched to 45 and boom!
Felt kinda stupid afterwards, but what's a man to do?
P.S. Great album that - Seldom Seen Kid.