Very poor aerial reception area - is an expensive hi gain aerial worth the cost vs using existing sat dish

Toggle sidebar Toggle sidebar
A

admin_exported

New member
Aug 10, 2019
2,556
4
0
Visit site
Just moved into home about 30 miles from midlands tv transmitter and in a valley dip with a large hill between bungalow and transmitter! As you can guess, the aerial signal is dire. All the other bungalows around here have got fancy multi X element aerials on huge poles, whereas mine has got an old cheapest-of-the-cheap job stuck ontop of a ten foot pole fixed to the chimney.

I'd got a quote of £200 -ish for a 'digital ready' aerial installation (I know, don't laugh, they're all at it!) but as this is only going to give me terrestrial and freeview, and I notice, there is an existing satellite dish on the SE wall leading to a cable in the living room, I reckon that Freesat with a fifty-quid box is my best cost effective solution for getting basic tv with an acceptable picture.

Am I right? Even a fancy aerial in my area is not going to produce, I would have thought, a picture as good as the satellite. I know I'll be losing some channels, but that aside, shall I ignore the aerial completely and buy a cheap box?

Thanks in advance for any advice.
 
daveh75

daveh75

Well-known member
Jul 31, 2008
1,056
456
19,570
Visit site
HNev:
Just moved into home about 30 miles from midlands tv transmitter and in a valley dip with a large hill between bungalow and transmitter! As you can guess, the aerial signal is dire. All the other bungalows around here have got fancy multi X element aerials on huge poles, whereas mine has got an old cheapest-of-the-cheap job stuck ontop of a ten foot pole fixed to the chimney.

I'd got a quote of £200 -ish for a 'digital ready' aerial installation (I know, don't laugh, they're all at it!) but as this is only going to give me terrestrial and freeview, and I notice, there is an existing satellite dish on the SE wall leading to a cable in the living room, I reckon that Freesat with a fifty-quid box is my best cost effective solution for getting basic tv with an acceptable picture.

Am I right? Even a fancy aerial in my area is not going to produce, I would have thought, a picture as good as the satellite. I know I'll be losing some channels, but that aside, shall I ignore the aerial completely and buy a cheap box?

Thanks in advance for any advice.

Go with the dish and Freesat/Sky!

By the sound's of it even with an aerial upgrade you wont get decent reception/full service.There is no such thing as an 'digital' aerial so if that's what the installers are claiming they'll fit i'd be dubious of their credentials.If you go the aerial route use a CAI and/or RDI-LB approved installer.

You can search for CAI approved installers in your area here, and RDI-LB installers here
 
RodhasGibson

RodhasGibson

Well-known member
Oct 10, 2008
191
9
18,595
Visit site
Hi There, The fact that you have the oldest aerial in the area, suggests to me that the previous owners decided to go the Satellite Route to get decent reception. Question is whether the dish is for sky or for Freesat.Both will give you a number of free to view channels [freesat was introduced primarily to give good reception to folk such as yourself, getting poor or nil tv reception.Not sure of current prices for the set top boxes though. Freesat boxes start at around £50 as for sky Boxes perhaps Dave 75 will come along and fill you in,better than I.Good Luck.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Thanks for your replies: as for what type of dish it is - the small circular sat dish has been there for three or more years so it must be an old Sky dish, as Freesat only recently started up, I understand.

The Freesat website says I can get a basic Bush box for £45 from Argus. This would do for me, I don't want to pay for a Sky subscription.

My only remaining question is - will I be able to just plug in the cable from the ex-Sky dish and that's it?
 
daveh75

daveh75

Well-known member
Jul 31, 2008
1,056
456
19,570
Visit site
HNev:

Thanks for your replies: as for what type of dish it is - the small circular sat dish has been there for three or more years so it must be an old Sky dish, as Freesat only recently started up, I understand.

The Freesat website says I can get a basic Bush box for £45 from Argus. This would do for me, I don't want to pay for a Sky subscription.

My only remaining question is - will I be able to just plug in the cable from the ex-Sky dish and that's it?

Sky and Freesat receive the same signal's from the same satellites,so providing the dish is still in good condition it's just a case of connecting it up to your Freesat box and away you go.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Thanks Dave and everyone,

Good news all around then - just plug and go.

Cheers,

HNev
 
C

Cofnchtr

Well-known member
Oct 4, 2007
146
0
18,590
Visit site
Hi,

Sure this isn't an older analogue SKY dish? I thought all Sky-digital dishes were oval?

If it is an older one, it'll be pointing the wrong direction and won't work with a newer digibox.

Cheers,

Cofnchtr.
 
C

Cofnchtr

Well-known member
Oct 4, 2007
146
0
18,590
Visit site
Hi,

Looks like a newer oval one to me so will probably work as long as there's no damage at the LNB end and the cable is OK.

Pretty cheap to replace either of these though.

Cheers,

Cofnchtr.
 
S

SpiceWeasel

New member
Apr 10, 2008
189
0
0
Visit site
Do you know anyone who has a SKY box that you could borrow, maybe a neighbour or friends/familly?
You could then plug in the box and view the free channels to see what the quality is like, you can also check the signal quality and strength from the service menu of the SKY box. I don't know how the free channel line up compares with SKY and Freesat but at least you will know that the dish is fully working before hand.

If the channel line up is the same on freesat/sky then you might be able to buy a cheap standard SKY box for less than £50, especially if theres any 2nd hand boxes on fleebay for example.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

TRENDING THREADS

Latest posts

Share this page

COMPANY
RESOURCES
FOLLOW
Top Bottom