Hi Yes. 2 attempts failed so I have written in word!!
After the pains of separation came the joys of hi-fi!
The current owner of a Pioneer VSX-LX55 and B&W 685’s, I have really enjoyed the huge upgrade in performance form the previous Panasonic Micro system.
Before I bought this system I demo’d MA RX1, RX2, and the 685’s with a combination of Marantz PM 6003, (as recommended by dealer, but perhaps the weak link), Rega Brio R, Rega DAC, Arcam DAC and Marantz MCR-603 and my preference, in a big way, was the Pioneer and 685’s. It had so much more muscle, a bigger, fuller sound, great bass and didn’t seem to me to lose anything in detail. In fact I found both the MA speakers to be very bright, to the point that I was happy not to listen to the RX6’s (perhaps a mistake in hindsight, as the MA’s were my favourites at the price point before auditioning.
So, the system I have is big (relatively) and surprisingly full and I have greatly enjoyed this over the last year. (All my music is mp3 or flac and I’m a big fan of Spotify, so currently connecting my laptop via hdmi to the Pioneer).
But, over the last year, as much as I enjoy the system, the bug is there and I find that the highs are somewhat sharp ( eg Alannis Morrissette’s jagged little pill), the bass and mid-range are muffled and less decisive than I would like and it’s time to start planning for the next step…
I was looking to demo the Dynaudio Focus 160, MA GX100, PMC Twenty.22 and Proac D18, but was happy when my local dealer offered MA GX50, PMC Twenty.22, Kef R300 ( heard a lot of good things) and my own 685’s for comparison.
The demo lasted over 2 hours, and I was very happy with the attentiveness of the dealer. Constant swapping backwards and forwards. I won’t forget when purchase time comes.
I asked for the Arcam A38 with either the Rega or Audiolab DAC’s. We used the new Arcam A19 amp and Rega DAC for the demo.
Must say that in my limited experience the new amp is impressive and was able to go loud on each of the speakers, but particular the low load PMC’s.
685’s I know these are good speakers and almost impossible to criticise at the price point, and at first listen I didn’t get the big difference with PMC’s, but they lack openness, clarity, rhythm and reality, and substitute this with greater perceived bass.
MA GX50- Wow. For such a small speaker (I must admit to having already discounted them as I wanted to listen to their bigger brother and a bigger budget), but in hindsight they are very impressive. Clarity and amazing bass. Might have to listen to them again – didn’t really give them a chance…
Kef R300 – After hearing such good reviews was really happy that the dealer had them available. At low volumes they seemed like a better version of the 685’. Tighter, smoother at the top end and with great bass performance, but once the volume creep’d up, the bass boom was intolerable. The dealer said it’s because of the room acoustics, and, moving around the room it was possible to find some sweet spots, but, whilst I don’t have any restrictions on moving rear ported speakers away from the rear wall, I was very disappointed. The dealer blamed the room, but I’m not sure…
PMC Twenty.22 The most expensive and hyped by some margin, I spent most of the 2 hours back and forwards between these and the 685’s. The difference took a little while for me to be clear. The more I listened to them the better they sounded, particularly with acoustic and female voices like Suzanne Vega. They really are very open, airy and clear and the comparison with the 685’s just got better and better. Then Massive Attack and Fluke. Maybe the 685’s bass response is artificially enhanced, but where was the bass? Don’t think I could live with lack or bass (perceived or real). Dealer suggested hooking up a REL 528 to make up the difference and that would be useful with its twin input when I get round to the home cinema setup. BUT. Impressed as I was/am, I just want one speaker to do it all. I know I won’t get FULL range from stand mounts, but a bit closer would be nice.
Looking forward to listening to the Focus 160’s. On paper my ideal speakers but a bit wary about amp requirements to see the best of them.
Other contenders are Proac D18 and ATC SCM19
Thanks for reading. Any opinions very welcome