Cripes Max, a hi fi "novice" with 5000+ posts!!!
Seriously, I've read lots of your posts, and my advice FWIW is to listen with your ears and not through the lens of a web forum if you will pardon the deliberate mixed metaphor.
Remember, anyone can be anyone to a degree on the net, and chances are there are a significant number of opinions (and remember that's all they are) are probably made up anyway and never really happened. I guess that this one is a lot more honest than most, but I'd wager its not completely 100% real. Advice is often best seasoned with salt, and in that context nothing is blander than forum-speak!