rich51080,
I never said more expensive means better!
What I was trying to point out was a 5 star product costing £200 is possibly far better that a 5 star product costing £70.
The ambiguity of WHF star system is shown up by this thread as it is very hard to talk in terms of 'best' when comparing reviews from very different price brackets.
I have no doubt that there are times when a 5 star cheap product is blown out of the water by a 3 star expensive product for example, when simply judging on sound performance, when you ignore things like value for money, functionality, usability, etc...
I grant you that it is possible that a cheap 5 star product could be better than a more expensive 5 star product. However, this is not so probable, as manufacturers charge as much as they think they can justify while being competative (to increase their profit margins).
Also, saying 'Bose blows' is a naive sweeping statement and while in my personal experience the few Bose products I have demoed were overpriced and an over emphas on the lows and the highs (and neglect the midrange), you can't throw the baby out with the bath water!
An example is in the area of active noise cancellation headphones where the Bose QC15 has been consistently judged (my numerous professional panels) as being the best product in this category by some margin. But if you don't need noise cancellation then I don't deny far better headphones can be found far cheaper. My personal choice of the Bose QC20i is based on suffering from migraines and I need more portability than the QC15. There will be times that I will use the active noise cancelling feature with NO music playing (when suffering from a migraine at work in a noisy environment). So for me the QC20i are the best fit for a very specific purpose. I also find the Bose tips comfortable during a migraine compared to earphones that get pushed into the ear canal - like my Klipsch X10i which I also use. Again, my B&W P3 serve my needs in a different situation.
The original cheese38 post was asking about earphones that have particularly 'strong bass', which I indicates an emphasis on bass is desired for cheese38. Therefore, I answered with a recommendation that might fit the sound style that cheese38 is looking for. Whereas you on the other hand are telling cheese38 to buy earphones with a different sound style which is totally disregarding cheese38 stated personal preference.