SAMSUNG AWARD WINNER

[swiftmick]

Hi everyone, just a small question.

Has anyone else experienced this?

I made a few comments on the what Hi Fi Magazine's choice in awarding the Samsung SMT-S7800 best freesat Oct of 2012.The comments I made questioned how and why the magazine came up with that decision ?

Only to find that my comments have been removed from the website?

The comments I made were all fact, and showed that the magazine had made a bit of a hash of the review.

Which then questioned the validity of the famous What Hi Fi? magazine awards.

So, the forums are here to help fellow audio enthusiasts. But God forbid you should question the reviewers employed by the magazine.

 

[Andy Clough]

swiftmick, I just checked and your original comments (dated Oct 21st, 2013) are still showing as 'published' and I can clearly see them on the review, so they weren't removed by me or anyone else on the editorial team. We welcome user feedback on all products, and you're perfectly entitled to disagree with our reviews and verdicts.

 

[spiny norman]

Only to find that my comments have been removed from the website?

What's the beef, chief? Your comments are still there, and plain for anyone to see.

(Good use of the ARI in that sentence by the way?)

 

[bigboss]

Yes, I can see your post which is on top of all others:

http://www.whathifi.com/review/samsung-smt-s7800/user-reviews

 

[swiftmick]

Ok thanks for the heads up guys, my fault. I couldn't find it.

Still don't alter the fact the award was wrongly given to the Samsung

Again my apologies

 

[bigboss]

Ok thanks for the heads up guys, my fault. I couldn't find it.

Still don't alter my opinion the award was wrongly given to the Samsung

Again my apologies

Fixed it for you. 🙂