restore my old Thorens, or upgrade to a new turntable (and which one to choose, Rega or Audio-Technica

_anonymus_

Active member
Oct 5, 2021
11
2
25
Hello everybody,
10 years ago, I bought a second-hand Thorens TD-160.
It is equipped with the tonearm of a TD-165 (TP11). I swapped the original cartridge for an Ortofon 2M (which I mounted from above, whereas the original cartridge was mounted from below). However, I can't get it aligned perfectly, so I hear a lot of distortion when spinning records.
Cables are all original so old. Switching from 33 tot 45 rpm doesn't work any more, only works when I manually put the belt into place.

I want to improve the sound quality of my vinyl, so now I am in doubt: do I put my money in restoring the old Thorens (have it aligned, RCA connectors, new housing, new power cables...) or do I just invest in a decent, fit-and-forget turntable like the Audio-Technica AT-LP7 or the Rega Planar 3?

Current set-up is a Pioneer VSX-521 receiver paired with a TC-750 phone preamp and Klipsch RF-52 floorstanding speakers.

I don't think the TC-750 is a high quality preamp, although it does a decent job.
As the Audio-Technica has a built-in preamp (that can be ruled out in case of further upgrades), this one looks appealing to me.
However, I can't find it in Europe, whereas the Rega is widely available here.

I am also planning in investing in new speakers (higher quality bookshelf speakers in stead of the current floorstanders) and maybe in a dedicated stereo receiver.

What would be your choice?
 
I am curious as to why you cannot get cartridge to align properly. However I would suggest the cost involved in getting the Thorens into good order and it's actual resale value might be prohibitive.
For a hassle free set-up I would suggest you look at new Project turntables and one of their cheaper phono preamps if you are in Europe.
The Debut Pro is excellent and not much more expensive than a P3
 

abacus

Well-known member
Sep 24, 2008
677
372
19,270
Investigate how much it will cost to refurbish as you will need to spend well over a grand to better the performance of a fully working 160.

If it is uneconomical to repair have a word with a dealer to try a few out to see what will suit your system best.

Bill
 
Investigate how much it will cost to refurbish as you will need to spend well over a grand to better the performance of a fully working 160.

If it is uneconomical to repair have a word with a dealer to try a few out to see what will suit your system best.

Bill
True, but there seems to be an issue with cartridge alignment and it has a non original tonearm.
It is never going to be a 'fully working 160' without refitting the correct tonearm.
 

EricLeRouge

Well-known member
Jan 15, 2020
51
28
570
I would definitely keep a TD160 over a Rega P3 or AT.
I have a TD145 (a semi-automatic version of the 160) and I took it to a specialist workshop run by an older guy who knows Thorens from back then, to have everything checked, set up and fine-tuned. It cost me €100 and it works like a charm eversince.
 

_anonymus_

Active member
Oct 5, 2021
11
2
25
I am curious as to why you cannot get cartridge to align properly.
I just had another go at it using the protractors from Vinyl Engine.
When I use the Thorens Baerwald Arc Protractor, I cannot find a setting where the stylus nicely follows the arc.
Using the 'stupid protractors' I think it is about right (although using these I have the feeling that I can get it aligned no matter how far I slide the cartridge front and back). However, I still have a lot of creaking when I play a record.
 

_anonymus_

Active member
Oct 5, 2021
11
2
25
I would definitely keep a TD160 over a Rega P3 or AT.
I have a TD145 (a semi-automatic version of the 160) and I took it to a specialist workshop run by an older guy who knows Thorens from back then, to have everything checked, set up and fine-tuned. It cost me €100 and it works like a charm eversince.
If I could find someone to do it for € 100 and I know it works perfectly afterwards, I wouldn't hesitate.
I was planning to bring it to Dr. Thorens in Holland (I live in Belgium), but he charges a lot more.
 
If I could find someone to do it for € 100 and I know it works perfectly afterwards, I wouldn't hesitate.
I was planning to bring it to Dr. Thorens in Holland (I live in Belgium), but he charges a lot more.
I am concerned that you cannot align the cartridge properly is due to the fact that the tonearm itself is not original and may be causing the problem.
 

_anonymus_

Active member
Oct 5, 2021
11
2
25
Just got the response.
Apparently there are some parts missing (compensation weight for the arm, among others) and the element is not mounted correctly.
Tone-arm should not be a problem with the TD-160.
Rough costs estimation is € 355 to get it in perfect playing condition.
What do you guys think, would this be worth it or do I look out for another table?
 

abacus

Well-known member
Sep 24, 2008
677
372
19,270
Nothing out today that costs around €355 (Or a lot more) will come anywhere close to the 160 so in my opinion worth it, however try negotiating as you may be able to get it lower, also have a look around elsewhere to see if anyone else can do it for a better price. (Make sure you get some form of warrantee)

Bill
 

Gray

Well-known member
Just got the response.
Apparently there are some parts missing (compensation weight for the arm, among others) and the element is not mounted correctly.
Tone-arm should not be a problem with the TD-160.
Rough costs estimation is € 355 to get it in perfect playing condition.
What do you guys think, would this be worth it or do I look out for another table?
That's a lot of money.
I can only say that I fitted RCA sockets on my 160S. It took ages to do it right - without any harm to the nice wooden plinth (they're mounted below it).
It takes effort to do things neatly.
So I do understand how someone could charge so much to do all that you require.
 

_anonymus_

Active member
Oct 5, 2021
11
2
25
This guy seems busy, he has a waiting list so it will be end '22 or beginning '23 before he can do it.
But I do think the Thorens is too good to let go, so I'll probably have it restored. I'll have a look around first to see if I can find quicker (and hopefully cheaper) alternatives.
In the meanwhile I will look out for a second-hand turntable to help me out until then.
 
Nothing out today that costs around €355 (Or a lot more) will come anywhere close to the 160 so in my opinion worth it, however try negotiating as you may be able to get it lower, also have a look around elsewhere to see if anyone else can do it for a better price. (Make sure you get some form of warrantee)

Bill
I would agree.
 

_anonymus_

Active member
Oct 5, 2021
11
2
25
So, because the waiting list at Dr. Thorens was a bit too long for me, I took the TD160 to the local HiFi specialist (a passionate man of age and an LFD Audio dealer).
I just picked it up and it is really singing now.
I heard it playing through an LFD amplifier and a pair of Fischer & Fischer speakers and wow, that sounded good.
But also through my more modest home system (Pioneer VSX-521, TC-750 preamp, B&W 660 speakers) it sounds really good.
It is not a complete restoration as Dr. Thorens would do, but for € 90 I am happy with it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DougK and Al ears

ASK THE COMMUNITY

TRENDING THREADS

Latest posts